The Lamarckian principle of modification through use does not, in
any case, nearly suffice as an interpretation of the transformations
of the organic world. It must be allowed that Lamarck's theory of
transformation was well founded at the time when it was advanced; it
not only attacked the doctrine of the immutability of species, but
sought for the first time to indicate the forces and influences which
must be operative in the transformations of species; it was therefore
well worth careful testing. Nevertheless it did not divert science from
its chosen path; very little notice was taken of it, and in the great
Cuvier's chronicle of scientific publications for 1809, not a syllable
is devoted to Lamarck's book, so strong was the power of prejudice.
But, although the new doctrine was thus ignored, it did not altogether
fall to the ground; it glimmered for a while in Germany, where it found
its champions in the 'Naturphilosophie' of the time, and especially in
Lorenz Oken, a peasant's son, born at Ortenau, near Offenburg, in 1783.
Oken professed views similar to those of Erasmus Darwin, Treviranus,
and Lamarck, though they were not clothed in such purely scientific
garb, being, in fact, bound up with the general philosophical
speculations which came increasingly into favour at that time, chiefly
through the writings of Schelling. In the same year, 1809, in which
Lamarck published his _Philosophie zoologique_, Oken's _Lehrbuch der
Naturphilosophie_ appeared.
This book is by no means simply a theory of descent; its scope is much
wider, including the phenomena of the whole cosmos; on the other hand,
it goes too little into details and is too indefinite to deserve its
title. Its way of playing with ideas, its conjectures and inferences
from a fanciful basis, make it difficult for us now to think ourselves
into its mode of speculation, but I should like to give some indication
of it, for it was just these speculative encroachments of the
'categories' of the so-called 'Naturphilosophie' which played a fatal
part in causing the temporary disappearance of the Evolution-theory
from science, so that, later on, it had to be established anew.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account