Thus Oken postulated, as the specific vehicle of life, a primitive
substance, in essence at least homogeneous. But he went further, and
maintained that his 'Urschleim' assumed _the form of vesicles_, of
which the various organisms were composed. 'The organic world has as
its basis an infinitude of such vesicles.' Who is not at once reminded
of the now dominant _Cell-theory_? And, in fact, thirty years later,
when the cell was discovered, Oken did claim priority for himself. In
so doing, he obviously confused the formulating of a problem with the
solving of it; he had, quite rightly, divined that organisms must be
built up of very minute concentrations of the primitive substance, but
he had never seen a cell, or proved the necessity for its existence, or
even attempted to prove it. His vesicle-theory was a pure divination, a
prevision of genius, but one which could not directly deepen knowledge;
it did not prompt, or even hasten, the discovery of the cell. Here,
as throughout in his natural philosophy, Oken built, not from beneath
upwards, by first establishing facts and then drawing conclusions from
them, but, inversely, he invented ideas and principles, and out of
them reconstructed the world. In this he differs essentially from his
predecessors Erasmus Darwin, Treviranus, and Lamarck, who all reasoned
inductively, that is, from observed data.
Thus the whole evolutionary movement was lost in indefiniteness;
because men wanted to find a reason for everything, they missed
even what might then have been explained. Moreover, the theory of
evolution still lacked a sufficiently broad basis of facts; the
'Naturphilosophie,' by its want of moderation, robbed it of all
credit; and it is not to be wondered at that men soon ceased to occupy
themselves with the problem of the evolution of the living world. A few
indeed held fast to the doctrine of evolution during the first third
of the century, but then it disappeared completely from the realm of
science.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account