It is impossible to estimate the effect of Darwin's book on _The
Origin of Species_, published in English in 1858, in German in 1859
unless we fully realize how completely the biologists of that time
had turned away from general problems. I can only say that we, who
were then the younger men, studying in the fifties, had no idea that
a theory of evolution had ever been put forward, for no one spoke of
it to us, and it was never mentioned in a lecture. It seemed as if all
the teachers in our universities had drunk of the waters of Lethe,
and had utterly forgotten that such a theory had ever been discussed,
or as if they were ashamed of these philosophical flights on the part
of natural science, and wished to guard their students from similar
deviations. The over-speculation of the 'Naturphilosophie' had left in
their minds a deep antipathy to all far-reaching deductions, and, in
their legitimate striving after purely inductive investigation, they
forgot that the mere gathering of facts is not enough, that the drawing
of conclusions is an essential part of the induction, and that a mass
of bare facts, however enormous, does not constitute a science.
One of my most stimulating teachers at that time, the gifted anatomist,
Jacob Henle, had written as a motto under his picture, 'There is a
virtue of renunciation, not in the province of morality alone, but
in that of intellect as well,' a sentence which expressly indicated
the desirability of refraining from all attempts to probe into the
more general problems of life. Thus the young students of that time
were nourished only on the results of detailed research, in part
indeed interesting enough, but in part dry and, because uncorrelated,
unintelligible in the higher sense, and only here and there awakening a
deeper interest, when, as in physiology and in embryology, they formed
a connected system in themselves. Without being fully clear as to what
was lacking, we certainly missed the deeper correlation of the many
separate disciplines.
It is therefore not to be wondered that Darwin's book fell like a
bolt from the blue; it was eagerly devoured, and while it excited in
the minds of the younger students delight and enthusiasm, it aroused
among the older naturalists anything from cool aversion to violent
opposition. The world was as though thunderstruck, as we can readily
see from the preface with which the excellent zoologist of Heidelberg,
Bronn, introduced his translation of Darwin's book, where he asks this
question among others, 'How will it be with you, dear reader, after you
have read this book?' and so forth.
But before I enter on a detailed examination of the contents of this
epoch-making book, I should like to say a few words about the man
himself, who thus revolutionized our thinking.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account