Of course there must also be unimportant changes in butterfly-markings
which depend solely on the internal play of forces in the determinant
system, and to this must be referred the markings of many of the
'variable' species whose variations are mere fluctuations in the
details of marking, which have therefore caused much trouble to the
systematists. Truly unimportant variations will rarely or never
combine into a 'constant' form, and the fact that there are species
which are 'variable' in such a high degree is enough to make us refer
their variations to their lack of importance, for if they possessed
any biological value the less valuable among them would gradually be
removed by selection. Perhaps the variable species of certain moths
like _Arctia caja_, and especially _Arctia plantaginis_, the little
'bear' of the Alps and Apennines, must be reckoned among these.
But from the fact that there are such fluctuations in the markings
of Lepidoptera, it seems to me that we must conclude that species
which show a high degree of constancy in their markings have been
influenced by selection, or by climatic influences which turned the
play of forces within the determinant system in the same direction in
all individuals. All these considerations and conclusions are quite
sound and serviceable theoretically, but they are difficult to apply
to individual cases, and where this is attempted it must be with the
greatest caution, and, if possible, on a basis of investigations
specially undertaken for the purpose; for how should we know whether
a species which to-day is highly variable may not a geological
epoch later become a very constant one? We must in any case assume
that marked fluctuations of characters are associated with many
transformations.
LECTURE XXVI
GERMINAL SELECTION (_continued_)
Germinal selection, spontaneous and induced--Climatic
forms of _Polyommatus phlæas_--Deformities--Excessive
augmentation of variations--Can it lead to the elimination
of a species?--Saltatory variations, copper-beech, weeping
trees--Origin of sexual distinguishing characters--Formation
of breeds among domesticated animals--Degenerate jaws--Human
teeth--Short-sightedness--Milk-glands--Small hands and feet--Ascending
variation--Talents, intellect--Combination of mental endowments--The
ultimate roots of heritable variation--There are only plus- and
minus-variations--Relations of the determinants to their
determinates--The play of forces in the determinant system of the
id--Germinal selection inhibited by personal selection--Objection on
the score of the minuteness of the substance of the germ-plasm.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account