Hitherto we have derived the variations of the determinants of the
germ-plasm, upon which we based the process of germinal selection,
from _chance local_ fluctuations in nutrition, such as must occur in
an individual id, independently of the nutrition of the other ids of
the same germ-plasm. But there are doubtless also influences which set
up similar nutritive changes in _all ids_, and by which, therefore,
all homologous determinants, in as far as they are sensitive to the
nutritive change in question, are affected in the same manner. To
this category belong changes in the external conditions of life, and
particularly climatic changes. It is, then, germinal selection alone
which brings about the presence of a majority of ids with determinants
varying in the same direction, and personal selection has no part
in the transformation of the species. Many years ago I instituted
experiments with a small butterfly, _Pararga egeria_, and these
showed that a heightened temperature so influenced the pupæ of this
form that the butterflies emerged with a different and deeper yellow
ground-colour, similar to that of the long-known southern variety
_Meione_. More thoroughly decisive, however, were the experiments on
_Polyommatus phlæas_, the small 'fire-butterfly,' which were carried
on in the eighties by Merrifield in England and by myself almost at
the same time. I shall discuss these later in more detail, and will
only say here that this butterfly, whose range extends from Lapland
to Sicily, occurs in two forms, the southern distinguished by a
'dusting' of deep black from the northern, in which the wing-surfaces
are of a pure red-gold. The experiments showed that the southern
form can be artificially produced by warmth, and the interpretation
must be that the direct influence of higher temperature affects the
quality of the nutritive fluids in the germ-plasm, and thereby at
the same time the determinants of one or more kinds of wing-scales
are caused to vary in all the ids in the same direction, in such a
fashion that they give rise to black scales instead of the former
red-gold ones. It is thus certain that there are external influences
which cause particular determinants to vary in a particular manner.
I call this form of germinal variation 'induced' germinal selection,
and contrast it with 'spontaneous' selection, which is caused, not by
extra-germinal influences, but by the chances of the intra-germinal
nutritive conditions, and which will, therefore, not readily occur at
the same time in all the ids of a germ-plasm, and so will not give rise
to variation of the same kind in the homologous determinants of all the
ids.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account