Whether in this case also the disease germs are transmitted through
the male sex-cells is not proved, as far as I am aware, but that this
can happen is shown by the transmission of syphilis from father to
child. That in this case, also, the exciting cause of the disease is a
micro-organism cannot be doubted, although it has not yet been proved.
Thus even the minute spermatozoon of Man can contain microbes, and
transmit them to the germ of a new individual.
This discussion of scientific questions ought not to be brought down
to the level of a play upon words, by bringing forward cases like the
above as evidence for the inheritance of 'acquired characters,' as was
done, for instance, by M. Nussbaum, who cited as a proof of this the
migration of the alga-cells which live in the endoderm of the green
freshwater Hydra into the ovum, which is originally colourless, and
originates in the ectoderm of the animal (Fig. 35_B_, p. 169, vol.
i). It seems to me better to make a precise distinction between the
transmission of extraneous micro-organisms through the germ-cells and
the handing on of the germ-plasm with the characters inherent in its
structure. Only the latter is inheritance in the strict scientific
sense, the former is infection of the germ.
Still less than the cases of inherited traumatic epilepsy can the
morbid constitution of the children of drunkards be regarded as a
proof of the inheritance of somatogenic characters, though this has
often been maintained. I will not lay any stress on the fact that the
allegation itself is, according to the most competent observers, such
as Dr. Thomas Morton[12], far from being established. But even if it
were quite certain that the numerous diseases of the nervous system,
amounting sometimes to mania, which are frequently observed in the
children of drunkards, were really _caused_ by the drinking of the
parents, it ought not to be overlooked that we have here to do not with
the hereditary transmission of somatic variations, but of variations
_directly_ induced in the germ-plasm of the reproductive cells, for
these are exposed to the influence of the alcohol circulating in the
blood, just as any other part of the body is. That by this means
variations in the germ-plasm can be brought about, and that these
may lead to morbid conditions in the children cannot be denied, and
ought not on _a priori_ grounds to be called in question. For we are
acquainted with many other influences--climatic, for instance--which
directly affect and cause variation in the germ-plasm. Whether this
is so in the case of drunkenness, and in what manner it comes about,
whether through direct action of the alcohol, or through infection of
the germ with some microbe, we must leave to the future to decide; the
whole question is out of place here; it can in no way help us to clear
up the problem with which we are now occupied.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account