The Expositor's Bible: The Book of DanielFarrar, F. W. (Frederic William)
Religion
The Expositor's Bible: The Book of Daniel
Farrar, F. W. (Frederic William)
Bible. Daniel -- Commentaries
[244] Mr. Bevan says that the verb for "defile" (גאל), as a ritual
term for the idea of ceremonial uncleanness, is post-exilic; the
Pentateuch and Ezekiel used טמא (_Comment._, p. 61). The idea
intended is that the three boys avoided meat which might have been
killed with the blood and offered to idols, and therefore was not
_Kashar_ (Exod. xxxiv. 15).
[245] Jos., _Vit._, iii. Comp. Isa. lii. 11.
[246] Mark vii. 19 (according to the true reading and translation).
[247] Acts x. 14.
[248] 1 Cor. xi. 25. This rigorism was specially valued by the
Essenes and Therapeutæ. See Derenbourg, _Palestine_, note, vi.
[249] Plato, _Alcib._, i. 37; Xen., _Cyrop._, i. 2. Youths entered
the king's service at the age of seventeen.
[250] Lit. "sadder." LXX., σκυθρωποί.
[251] LXX., κινδυνεύσω τῷ ἰδίῳ τραχήλῳ.
[252] Perhaps the Assyrian _matstsara_, "guardian" (Delitzsch). There
are various other guesses (Behrmann, p. 5).
[253] Heb., זֵרֹעִים; LXX., σπέρματα; Vulg., _legumina_. Abn Ezra
took the word to mean "rice." Comp. Deut. xii. 15, 16; 1 Sam. xvii.
17, 18. Comp. Josephus (_Vit._, iii.), who tells us how the Jewish
priests, prisoners in Rome, fed on σύκοις καὶ καρύοις.
[254] Ewald, _Antiquities_, p. 131 f.
[255] Pusey (p. 17) quotes from Chardin's notes in Harmer (_Obs._,
lix.): "I have remarked that the countenance of the Kechicks (monks)
are, in fact, more rosy and smooth than those of others, and that
those who fast much are, notwithstanding, very beautiful, sparkling
with health, with a clear and lively countenance."
[256] The _Chartummîm_ are like the Egyptian ἱερογραμματεῖς. It is
difficult to conceive that there was less chance of pollution in
being elaborately trained in heathen magic and dream-interpretation
than in eating Babylonian food. But this was, so to speak, _extra
fabulam_. It did not enter into the writer's scheme of moral
edification. If, however, the story is meant to imply that these
youths accepted the heathen training, though (as we know from tablets
and inscriptions) the incantations, etc., in which it abounded were
intimately connected with idolatry, and were entirely unharmed by it,
this may indicate that the writer did not disapprove of the "Greek
training" which Antiochus tried to introduce, so far as it merely
involved an acquaintance with Greek learning and literature. This is
the view of Grätz. If so, the writer belonged to the more liberal
Jewish school which did not object to a study of the _Chokmath
Javanîth_, or "Wisdom of Javan" (Derenbourg, _Palestine_, p. 361).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account