The Expositor's Bible: The Book of DeuteronomyHarper, Andrew
Religion
The Expositor's Bible: The Book of Deuteronomy
Harper, Andrew
Bible. Deuteronomy -- Commentaries
But, as a matter of fact, no falling off in spirituality took place
after Deuteronomy. Wellhausen says that with law freedom came to
an end, and this was the death of prophecy. But he can support his
thesis only by denying the name of prophet to all the prophets after
Jeremiah. It is difficult to see the basis of such a distinction. It
is judged by this, if by nothing else--that it compels Wellhausen
to deny that the author of Second Isaiah is a prophet. That he
wrote anonymously is held to prove that he felt this himself. Now a
view so extraordinarily superficial has no root, and every reader
of that most touching and sublime of all the Old Testament books
will simply stand amazed at the depth of the critical prejudice
which could dictate such a judgment. If the post-Deuteronomic
prophets are not prophets, then there are no prophets at all, and
the whole discussion becomes a useless logomachy. But even if
Ezekiel and Second Isaiah and the rest are not prophets, they are
at least full of spiritual life and power, so that the decay of
spiritual religion which the adoption of Deuteronomy is supposed
to have brought about must be considered purely imaginary on that
ground also. And this contention is strengthened by the theories
of the critical school themselves. If the bulk of the Psalms, as
all critics incline to believe, or all of them, as some say, are
post-exilic, then the first centuries of the post-exilic period must
have been the most spiritually minded epoch in Israelite history.
The depth of religious feeling exhibited in the Psalms, and the
comprehension of the inwardness of man's true relation to God by
which they are penetrated, are the exact contrary of the externality
and superficiality which the introduction of written law is said to
have produced. So long as the Psalms were being written religious
life must have been vigorous and healthy, and to date the beginnings
of Pharisaic externalism from Josiah's day must consequently be an
error.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account