The Expositor's Bible: The Book of DeuteronomyHarper, Andrew
Religion
The Expositor's Bible: The Book of Deuteronomy
Harper, Andrew
Bible. Deuteronomy -- Commentaries
After what has been said it is scarcely necessary to discuss Duhm's
views of the opposition between prophecy and Deuteronomy. It will be
sufficient to ask how the latter can have turned against prophecy,
when it is in its essence an embodiment of prophetic principles in
law, and was introduced and supported by prophets. But, it may be
said, after all prophecy did decay, and ultimately die, and that too
during the period after Deuteronomy. Is there not in that admitted
fact a presumption that this law did work against prophecy? If so,
then it is more than met by the fact that the decay of spiritual
religion became noticeable only some centuries after this, and
that the immediate effect of Deuteronomy was rather to deepen and
intensify religion, and to keep it alive amid all the vicissitudes
of the Captivity and Return. Moreover the break-up of the national
life was sufficient to account for the slow decay and final
cessation of prophecy. From the first, prophecy had been concerned
with the building up of a nation which should be faithful to Yahweh.
Its main function had been to interpret and to foretell the great
movements and crises of national life--to read God's purpose in
the great world-movements and to proclaim it. With Israel's death
as a nation the field of prophecy became gradually circumscribed,
and ultimately its voice ceased. Consequently, though in the main
the final cessation of prophecy was connected with the rise of
externalism in religion and with the great decay of spiritual life
in the two or three centuries before Christ, the destruction of the
nation would account for the feebleness of prophecy during a period
when the inner spiritual life was flourishing as it flourished after
Deuteronomy. Moreover, as religion became more inward and personal,
prophecy, in the Old Testament sense, had less place. Though in New
Testament times spiritual life and spiritual originality and power
were more present than at any time in the world's history, prophecy
did not revive. In the whole New Testament there is not one purely
prophetic book save the Revelation, and that is apocalyptic more
than simply prophetic; and though there was an order of prophets in
the early Church, if they had any special function other than that
of preachers their office soon died out. If then the denationalising
of religion and its growth in individualism and inwardness in New
Testament times prevented the revival of prophecy, we may surely
gather that the same things, and not the introduction of written
law, brought it to an end in the Old Testament.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account