The false assumptions of "democracy"Ludovici, Anthony M. (Anthony Mario)
Philosophy
The false assumptions of "democracy"
Ludovici, Anthony M. (Anthony Mario)
Democracy; Great Britain -- Social conditions; Social problems
A child will travel some distance and wear itself out in overcoming any
number of obstacles, if it be started off in pursuit of some alluring
object by someone whose word its experience has not yet taught it to
doubt. The alluring object may be entirely mythical--no matter! Granted
that the object has been made to appear sufficiently desirable, the
child will pursue its quest, sometimes with heroic perseverance. But
is there anyone prepared to maintain that the full-grown adult would
behave any differently under the influence of similar inducements?
Allowing for the difference between the minds of children and of
adults, and postulating for the adult an object which, though quite as
chimerical as that chosen for the child, is yet of a kind calculated to
fire his imagination, does anyone really question whether the adult’s
pursuit of it would be fully as eager and tenacious as that of the
child?
Consider, for instance, the time-honoured method of obtaining votaries
and adherents for any anti-social scheme. Certain states of mind or
body are first posited by the agitators, or would-be reformers, as
highly desirable; they are then shown to be unrealisable in the social
scheme which it is [p181] proposed to destroy; and finally humanity
is told that by destroying the social scheme already existing, those
desirable states of mind or body will be procured and enjoyed. These
hypothetical states of mind or body which are unrealisable in the
social scheme selected for destruction may be entirely fantastic and
unrealisable anywhere or how, but this objection the agitators do
not trouble to discuss; all they say is: “Here we hold up before you
certain desirable states of mind or body” (call them, if you will,
“etherealness” and “imponderability,”--qualities that would enable
those possessing them to overcome gravitation and all its concomittant
inconveniences) “these desirable states of mind or body can be obtained
only by breaking up certain traditions. Break up these traditions, and
you will possess them.”
It will be seen at once that the examples chosen, “etherealness” and
“imponderability,” are sufficiently extravagant to strike even the
meanest intelligence as being absurd, and an anti-social agitator
depending upon such desiderata alone would stand but a poor chance of
gaining followers. Substitute the words representing these vaporous
qualities, however, by another word which, though representing a
quality equally illusory, nevertheless does not strike the average man
immediately as being unrealisable, and the insidious operation of false
desiderata straightway becomes evident.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account