The false assumptions of "democracy"Ludovici, Anthony M. (Anthony Mario)
Philosophy
The false assumptions of "democracy"
Ludovici, Anthony M. (Anthony Mario)
Democracy; Great Britain -- Social conditions; Social problems
Most honest political thinkers have realised by now, for instance,
how visionary and unreal is the accepted notion of the reign of
“Justice”--not the justice that is administered [p182] in our Courts
of Law, or which we strive to exercise in daily life, but the
_justice immanente_ of Gambetta, already discussed, in which natural
inequalities and their accompanying disabilities and inconveniences
will be for ever removed or neutralised. But the glaring impossibility
of this desideratum, and the consequent meaninglessness of the word
used to designate it, does not seem to hinder millions from declaring
themselves ready to fight and to lose their blood and their lives in
trying to effect its realisation. And the same may be said of the ideas
embodied in the words “Liberty,” “Equality,” “Fraternity,” etc.
Given sufficient ingenuity in the agitator, therefore, it may be taken
for granted that the grand method of fomenting social upheavals is:
(1) to postulate a state of mind or body that is impossible in the
society which it is intended to destroy--the fact that the particular
mental or bodily state would be impossible in any society is either
judiciously concealed, or else not known to the agitator; (2) to
make the name for that particular state of mind or body a household
word representing a universal desideratum; and (3) to exploit any
existing disaffection, from whatever cause, in order to add momentum
to the general desire to see this hypothetical state of mind or body
realised by fair means or foul. In this way it is possible to make
millions destroy opposing millions, and violence outrival violence,
without anyone becoming aware, until too late, of the futility of the
conflict and of the criminality of the hoax. Aye, in the exhaustion and
confusion that [p183] follow, people are necessarily so busy overcoming
the multifarious difficulties that the struggle has created, that
frequently they have not even the time, much less the composure, to
ask themselves whether they have really obtained that for which they
destroyed their fellows, their own homes, and their civilisation. It is
in this way that false ideas often escape condemnation and exposure.
The tyranny of words and the ideas they represent, whether sound or
unsound, is therefore obvious enough; and, in the history of peoples it
is the principal tyranny of all. Beside it the tyranny of individual
monarchs is mere child’s play, and the deeds of a national hero only
stage effect. Where the ideas have been false, however, where the
desiderata striven and struggled for have been wholly chimerical, this
tyranny stands for the most prodigious romanticism of human life,--a
romanticism which, like all romanticism, has to be paid for very
heavily, and the price of which is frequently the peace, happiness and
order of centuries.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account