At Berlin, where open and covered filters were used side by side at Stralau for twenty years, it was found that, bacterially, the open filters were, except in severe winter weather, more efficient. It was long supposed that this was caused by the sterilizing action of the sunlight upon the water in the open filters. This result, however, was not confirmed elsewhere, and it was finally discovered, in 1893, that the higher numbers were due to the existence of passages in corners on the columns of the vaulted roof and around the ventilators for the underdrains, through which, practically, unfiltered water found its way into the effluent. This at once removes the evidence in favor of the superior bacterial efficiency of open filters and suggests the necessity of preventing such passages. The construction of a ledge all around the walls and pillars four inches wide and a little above the gravel, as shown in the sketch, might be useful in this way, and the slight lateral movement of the water in the sand above would be of no consequence. The sand would evidently make a closer joint with the horizontal ledge than with the vertical wall. [Illustration: FIG. 2.] In regard to the probable requirement or advisability of covers for filters in the United States, I judge, from the European experience, that places having January temperatures below the freezing-point will have considerable trouble from open filters, and would best have covered filters. Places having higher winter temperatures will be able to get along with the ice which may form on open filters, and the construction of covers would hardly be advisable except under exceptional local conditions, as, for instance, with a water with an unusual tendency to algæ growths. I have drawn a line across a map of the United States on this basis (shown by the accompanying plate) and it would appear that places far north of the line would require covered filters, and that those south of it would not, while for the places in the immediate vicinity of the line (comparable to Hamburg and Altona) there is room for discussion. In the United States covered filters have been constructed at St. Johnsbury, Vt., Somersworth, N. H., Albany, N. Y., Ashland, Wis., and Grand Forks, N. Dak., all of these places being considerably north of the above-mentioned line. The filter at Lawrence, Mass., with a mean January temperature of about 25°, is not covered, but serious difficulty and expense have been experienced at times from the ice, so much so that it has been repeatedly recommended to cover it. Open filters have also been in use for many years at Hudson and Poughkeepsie, N. Y., with mean January temperatures about 24°; and although considerable difficulty has been experienced from ice at times, these filters, particularly the ones at Poughkeepsie, have been kept in very serviceable condition at all times, notwithstanding the ice.