In fact, let there be in space a surface _A_, on this surface a line
_B_, on this line a point _M_. Let C_{0} be the aggregate of all series
[Sigma]. Let C_{1} be the aggregate of all the series [Sigma], such that
at the end of corresponding movements the finger is found upon the
surface _A_, and C_{2} or C_{3} the aggregate of series [Sigma] such
that at the end the finger is found on _B_, or at _M_. It is clear,
first that C_{1} will constitute a cut which will divide C_{0}, that
C_{2} will be a cut which will divide C_{1}, and C_{3} a cut which will
divide C_2. Thence it results, in accordance with our definitions, that
if C_{3} is a continuum of _n_ dimensions, C_{0} will be a physical
continuum of _n_ + 3 dimensions.
Therefore, let [Sigma] and [Sigma]' = [Sigma] + [sigma] be two series
forming part of C_{3}; for both, at the end of the movements, the finger
is found at _M_; thence results that at the beginning and at the end of
the series [sigma] the finger is at the same point _M_. This series
[sigma] is therefore one of those which correspond to movements where
the finger does not budge. If [Sigma] and [Sigma] + [sigma] are not
regarded as distinct, all the series of C_{3} blend into one; therefore
C_{3} will have 0 dimension, and C_{0} will have 3, as I wished to
prove. If, on the contrary, I do not regard [Sigma] and [Sigma] +
[sigma] as blending (unless [sigma] = _S_ + _S'_, _S_ and _S'_ being
inverses), it is clear that C_{3} will contain a great number of series
of distinct sensations; because, without the finger budging, the body
may take a multitude of different attitudes. Then C_{3} will form a
continuum and C_{0} will have more than three dimensions, and this also
I wished to prove.
We who do not yet know geometry can not reason in this way; we can only
verify. But then a question arises; how, before knowing geometry, have
we been led to distinguish from the others these series [sigma] where
the finger does not budge? It is, in fact, only after having made this
distinction that we could be led to regard [Sigma] and [Sigma] + [sigma]
as identical, and it is on this condition alone, as we have just seen,
that we can arrive at space of three dimensions.
We are led to distinguish the series [sigma], because it often happens
that when we have executed the movements which correspond to these
series [sigma] of muscular sensations, the tactile sensations which are
transmitted to us by the nerve of the finger that we have called the
first finger, persist and are not altered by these movements. Experience
alone tells us that and it alone could tell us.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account