I have dwelt, no doubt, at too great length upon one aspect only of our
author's varied and well-balanced discussion of the problems and
concepts of scientific theory. Of the hypotheses in the narrower sense
and of the value of direct empirical control, he has also spoken with
the authority and the originality which belong to his position. And in
dealing with the foundations of mathematics he has raised one or two
questions of great philosophical import into which I have no time, even
if I had the right, to enter here. In particular, in speaking of the
essence of mathematical reasoning, and of the difficult problem of what
makes possible novel results in the field of pure mathematics, M.
Poincaré defends a thesis regarding the office of 'demonstration by
recurrence'--a thesis which is indeed disputable, which has been
disputed and which I myself should be disposed, so far as I at present
understand the matter, to modify in some respects, even in accepting the
spirit of our author's assertion. Yet there can be no doubt of the
importance of this thesis, and of the fact that it defines a
characteristic that is indeed fundamental in a wide range of
mathematical research. The philosophical problems that lie at the basis
of recurrent proofs and processes are, as I have elsewhere argued, of
the most fundamental importance.
These, then, are a few hints relating to the significance of our
author's discussion, and a few reasons for hoping that our own students
will profit by the reading of the book as those of other nations have
already done.
Of the person and of the life-work of our author a few words are here,
in conclusion, still in place, addressed, not to the students of his own
science, to whom his position is well known, but to the general reader
who may seek guidance in these pages.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account