New England -- History -- Colonial period, ca. 1600-1775
An established church was a necessity from all three standpoints, of
religion, morals, and politics. Here and there, a few zealots might
organize their own congregations and support a preacher; but any sort of
congregational church government was out of the question for the
overwhelming mass of the people, who were ignorant and indifferent, but
still superstitiously devoted to the old Roman forms. The moral
sanctions of the time were, moreover, far more closely involved with
religion than they are to-day, and the church was far more essential as
a prop to a government none too strong. The situation called for the
opportunist policy which the Queen always favored in every difficulty.
Whatever may have been her own religious beliefs or lack of them, which
cannot now be known, she never cared for religious persecution, but she
cared everything for a strong and united England. Although conformity
was necessary to prevent the disintegration of the national life, the
standards to which she required men to conform were purposely left so
vague as to permit all but the most advanced of Protestant sectaries and
most irreconcilable of Romanists to become members of the Church of
England.
Opportunism may temporarily save a dangerous situation, but cannot be
pursued successfully as a permanent policy. The course of events led
extreme Catholics to feel that the Church had advanced so far that they
could not follow it, and the ultra-Puritans to consider that it had
stopped so short that they could not stay for it. To an opposition, all
things, theoretically, seem possible. The practical difficulties are for
those who have the responsibility of power. By the end of Elizabeth's
reign, the Catholics realized that the most they could hope for would be
toleration; and the real struggle for the control of the organization
lay between the Puritans and those who wished the Church to continue its
middle course. It must be pointed out, that this struggle of the Puritan
Nonconformists was in no sense for toleration. They had as little
thought of it as the Inquisition itself, nor did they exercise it when
in power, either in old or New England. In that regard, the Separatist
John Robinson, preaching to his little congregation in Leyden, was as
far ahead of the Puritan leaders in England, as Roger Williams was of
the leaders of Massachusetts.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account