The "free press" : $b portrait of a monopolyMarion, George
History
The "free press" : $b portrait of a monopoly
Marion, George
Press -- United States
This reporting formula is what the American news industry calls “true
and unbiased news.” It is regarded as something holy. A more than
religious fervor marks the industry’s references to it. Kent Cooper,
executive director of A.P., admits that it was not “the result of
philosophic study or prayer,” but he is proud that A.P. puts “into
forceful and lasting effect the moral concept that necessity had
invented.” He further calls it the “greatest moral concept ever
developed in America and given to the world.”
A second’s thought is enough to reveal that there is nothing “moral”
about the concept at all. The successful agency formula does not
require “truth.” It requires only the transmission of views or “facts”
acceptable and useful to _all capitalist newspaper owners_. It does not
eliminate bias. _It merely eliminates differences between individual
publishers and reduces reporting to the common bias of owners as a
group._ This formula for standardized treatment of events and opinions
is completely devoid of moral content. It has melted all varieties of
information, all events and interrelations, down to one kind of easily
sold and exchanged piece of goods: the commodity, news.
Though United Press is today as pompous as A.P. about the supposed
“objectivity” of American agency “news,” Roy Howard was franker when
he was fighting an uphill battle for U.P.’s life. He then complained
bitterly of A.P.’s monopolistic practices in “collecting and selling
a basic journalistic commodity--news--in a highly competitive field.”
He also said: “I do not subscribe to the general idea that news and
opinion are two different and easily separated elements.” Consider
news about Negroes, for instance, as handled by the agencies. Most of
it emanates from Southern newspapers with avowed lily-white views; it
is for distribution to all subscribers but must not “offend” the large
bloc of Southern papers. So it is all bias and a continent wide.
Oddly enough, labor journalism had to solve the same problem that led
the capitalist agencies to their news formula. The American Federation
of Labor established Federated Press in 1919 to serve the labor press,
chiefly weekly and monthly membership journals. The labor movement was
and is rent by factions; jurisdictional feuds are topped by the present
division of labor into the A. F. of L. and C.I.O. camps. Yet Federated
Press has always been able to supply news acceptable to warring
factions and rival unions. The agency never pretended, however, that it
was non-partisan in a larger sense. F.P. Chief Carl Haessler said:
The management of the Federated Press has never subscribed to the
hypocritical assertion of the capitalist newspapers that news can
be without bias. The Federated Press is very careful about facts
but they are presented with a decidedly pro-labor interpretation
just as we believe the capitalist press interprets news so that it
becomes pro-capitalist.
Remote Control
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account