Free thought; Modernism (Christian theology) -- Catholic Church; Religion and science; Teaching, Freedom of
above has another tendency. The entire case is hidden in obscurity
(_Hefele_, Conc. Gesch., 2d ed., III, 557 _seq._).
Furthermore, it has been said that at the time when the universities were
in close union with the Church, medical science could not advance because
the Church had prohibited human _anatomy_ (Prof. _J. H. van’t Hoff_, Neue
Freie Presse, December 29, 1907). In amplification it was said: “_Boniface
VIII._ had forbidden every anatomical dissection of a body” (_O.
Zoeckler_, Theologie und Naturwissenschaft, 1877, I, 342). What is true of
this assertion?
In the first place, _Boniface VIII._ did not forbid anatomy. He
merely prohibited in 1299 and 1300 the hideous custom then
prevailing regarding the bodies of noblemen who had died away from
home: they were disembowelled, dissected, and boiled, for the
purpose of removing the flesh from the bones so that the latter
could be transported the more easily. This process had nothing to
do with anatomy. The wish to possess the bones of the dead did not
seem to the Pope a sufficient reason for treating the human body
in such a way (Cfr. _Michael_, Gesch. des deutschen Volkes III,
1903, 433). Nor does history know of any other prohibition of
anatomy by the Church. It tells us, however, that _Frederick II._
in his excellent rules for the benefit of his Sicilian kingdom in
the regulation of medical science among other things emphasizes
the study of surgery: he ordered that no one be allowed to
practise surgery who could not show by attestation of his
professors that he had studied surgery for at least one year,
especially that he had learned at school how to dissect bodies; a
physician must be perfect in anatomy, else he may not undertake
operations (_Michael_, l. c. 430). This was done and practised
under the eyes of the Church. The accusers also seem ignorant of
the fact that bodies of those executed were given to universities
for dissection. In the year 1336 the medical students of
Montpellier, the famous medical school under the immediate
direction of the Church (see above, page 154) were granted the
privilege of obtaining once a year an executed criminal’s body for
dissection. The same privilege was extended to the medical
students of Lerida by King _Juan I._ on June 3, 1391, who decreed
that the delinquent should be drowned _pro speriencia seu anatomia
fienda_ (_Denifle_, Die Universitaeten des Mittelalters, I, 1885,
507).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account