Free thought; Modernism (Christian theology) -- Catholic Church; Religion and science; Teaching, Freedom of
The story is also circulated that the fourth Lateran Council in
1215 prohibited monks from studying natural sciences and medicine
(Deutschoester. Lehrerzeitung 15th Dec., 1909). It will suffice to
quote this particular decree of the Lateran Council: “No clergyman
is allowed to pronounce capital sentence, nor to execute it, nor
to be present at its execution. No clergyman is allowed to draw up
a document concerning a death sentence: at the courts this should
be done by laymen. No clergyman is allowed to assume command of
Rotarians (freebooters), of archers or any others who shed human
blood; no subdeacon, deacon, or priest is allowed to practise that
part of surgery by which cutting and burning is done, nor must any
one pronounce a benediction at an ordeal” (_Hefele_, Koncil.
Gesch., 2d ed., V, 1887, 887). This will thoroughly dispose of
that charge.
Just as briefly may we settle the story of _Columbus_ having been
excommunicated because of his intention to discover new lands. It
is said that the “Spanish clergy denounced his plans as against
the faith, and that the Council of Salamanca excommunicated him”
(_W. Draper_, ibid. 163). This is a fairy tale. The truth is, that
King _Ferdinand_ and Queen _Isabella_ referred the plans of the
bold Genoese to a council of scientists and ecclesiastical
dignitaries, which was held in the Dominican Monastery of
Salamanca, _Columbus_ being present. There never was a Council of
Salamanca. _Weiss_ writes in his “History of the World”: “Much has
been surmised concerning the objections and their refutation. It
is only certain that the majority rejected the plan as impossible
of execution, and that _Columbus_ won over a minority of them,
especially the priests, among whom the learned Dominican _Deza_
deserves mention” (Weltgesch. VII, 187). _Denthofen_, in his
biography of _Columbus_, says: “The Dominican Fathers supported
him during the long time the conference lasted, and even defrayed
the expenses of his journey. Father _Diego de Deza_, chief
professor of theology, was convinced by the reasons of _Columbus_,
and in turn convinced the more learned of his confrères. The
majority, however, thought the idea but a phantom, while others
deemed it impracticable. The conference adjourned without coming
to any definite decision” (Christof Columbus, Eine biographische
Skizze ..., 1878, 21). _Columbus_ found his warmest friend in the
learned Father _Juan Perez_, Guardian of the Franciscan Monastery
of St. Maria de la Rabida. Within the quiet walls of this cloister
_Columbus’_ plans were disclosed for the first time in Spain, and
admired and resolved upon. _Perez_ spoke untiringly to Isabella in
favour of the plan, and even aided _Columbus_ in gathering men for
his crew. This is the fact about the anathema the Church is paid
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account