Free thought; Modernism (Christian theology) -- Catholic Church; Religion and science; Teaching, Freedom of
“_Kant’s_ critical philosophy,” says _Paulsen_, “gives to
knowledge what belongs to it—the entire world of phenomena, for
the freest investigation; on the other hand, it gives to faith its
eternal right, viz., the interpretation of life and the world
according to their value” (Immanuel Kant, 1898, 6). “Faith does
not simply rest upon proofs, but upon practical necessity”; “it
does not come from the intellect, but from the heart and will”
(Einleitung in die Philosophie, 10th ed., 1903, 271, 269).
“Religion is not a science, hence it cannot be proved nor
disproved.” “Therefore man’s view of the world does not depend on
the intellect, but solely on his will.... The ultimate and highest
truths, truths by which man lives and for which he dies, have not
their source in scientific knowledge, but come from the heart and
from the individual will.” In a similar strain _R. Falkenberg_
writes: “The views of the world growing out of the chronology of
the human race, as the blossoms of a general process of
civilization, are not so much thoughts as rhythms of thinking, not
theories but views, saturated with appreciations.... Not only
optimism and pessimism, determinism and doctrine of freedom, but
also pantheism and individualism, idealism and materialism, even
rationalism and sensualism, have their roots ultimately in the
affections, and even while working with the tools of reason remain
for the most part matters of faith, sentiment, and resolve”
(Geschichte der neuen Philosophie, 5th ed., 1905, p. 3).
You may look up any books or magazines of modern philosophy or
Protestant theology, and you will find in all of them “that faith
is a kind of conviction for which there is no need of proof” (_H.
Luedemann_, Prot. Monatshefte IX, 1903, 367). This emotional faith
has been introduced into Protestant theology especially by
_Schleiermacher_. It is also this view of the more recent
philosophy that the modernists have adopted. They themselves
confess: “The _modernists_ in accord with modern psychology
distinguish clearly between knowledge and faith. The intellectual
processes which lead to them appear to the modernists altogether
foreign to and independent of one another. This is one of our
fundamental principles” (Programma dei Modernisti (1908), 121).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account