"That is the view which the French government has adopted," said the under-secretary. "Moreover, we have additional evidence: yours, M. Philippe Morestal. That evidence the government, through an excessive feeling of scruple, has not wished to recognize officially. As a matter of fact, it appeared to us less firm, more undecided, at the second hearing than at the first. But, such as it is, it assumes a peculiar value in my eyes, because it corroborates that of the two other witnesses. M. Philippe Morestal, do you maintain the terms of your deposition, word for word?" Philippe rose, looked at his father, pushed back Marthe, who came running up to him, and replied, in a low voice: "No, monsieur le ministre." CHAPTER VII MARTHE ASKS A QUESTION The conflict was immediate. Between Morestal and Philippe, the duel set in at once. The events of the previous days had cleared the way for it: at the first word, they stood up to each other like irreconcilable adversaries, the father spirited and aggressive, the son anxious and sad, but inflexible. Le Corbier at once foresaw a scene. He went out of the tent, ordered the sentry to stand away, made sure that the group of Germans could not hear the sound of the raised voices. Then, after carefully closing the fly, he returned to his place. "You are mad! You are mad!" said Morestal, who had come up to his son. "How dare you?" And Jorance joined in: "Come, come, Philippe ... this is not serious.... You are not going to back out, to withdraw...." Le Corbier silenced them and, addressing Philippe: "Explain yourself, monsieur," he said. "I do not understand." Philippe looked at his father again and, slowly, in a voice which he strove to render firm as he spoke, answered: "I say, monsieur le ministre, that certain particulars in my evidence are not accurate and that it is my duty to correct them." "Speak, monsieur," said the under-secretary, with some harshness. Philippe did not hesitate. Facing old Morestal, who was quivering with indignation, he began, as though he were in a hurry to get it over: "First of all, Private Baufeld did not say things that were quite as clear as those which I repeated. The words used were obscure and incoherent." "What! Why, your declarations are precise...." "Monsieur le ministre, when I gave my evidence for the first time before the examining-magistrate, I was under the shock of my father's arrest. I was under his influence. It seemed to me that the incident would have no consequences if the arrest had been effected on German territory; and, when relating Private Baufeld's last words, in spite of myself, without knowing it, I interpreted them in the sense of my own wishes. Later on, I understood my mistake. I am now repairing it." He stopped. The under-secretary turned over his papers, no doubt read through Philippe's evidence and asked: "As far as concerns Private Baufeld, have you nothing to add?"