The Frontiers of Language and Nationality in EuropeDominian, Leon
History
The Frontiers of Language and Nationality in Europe
Dominian, Leon
Europe -- Languages; Nationalism
Among the Celtic-speaking peoples, we have in the highlands of
Scotland, in the mountains of Wales, in western Ireland and in the
interior of Brittany, remnants of two distinct forms of Celtic
speech. These diverse populations have, in common, only their
Celtic speech, and are not related, one to the other, by race. As a
matter of fact, the Scotch, the Welsh and the Bretons are excellent
representatives of the three most divergent races of Europe. The
Armorican-speaking Bretons are Alpine by race, the Cymric-speaking
Welshmen are Mediterranean, while the Gaelic-speaking Scots are
Nordic. In short, there is today neither a Celtic race nor any
recognizable remnant of it. If one of these three peoples be
Celtic in bodily characters, the other two must of necessity not
be Celtic, and furthermore, if we designate any one of the three
as Celtic by race, we must include in that term other distant
populations which by no stretch of the imagination can be so
regarded.
The literary revival of some Celtic dialects may be interesting,
but it will only serve to keep the Celtic-speaking populations
still more out of touch with the march of modern progress. In the
long run the fate of Erse, Gaelic, Cymric and Armorican is certain.
They will be engulfed by the French language on the continent, and
by the English speech in the British Isles, just as Cornish and
Manx have become extinct within a century.
In eastern Europe, the Slavic tongue of Bohemia and Moravia, known
as Czech, was fifty years ago on the point of utter collapse, but
the literary revival of Bohemia has been successful because it
had for support on the east a solid mass of Slavic speech and the
political power of Pan-Slavism, and in consequence was able to hold
its own against the encroaching German. These Slavic dialects all
through eastern Europe and the minor tongues elsewhere are greatly
handicapped by the lack of books, newspapers and good literary
forms. In the case of Erse and Cymric the difficulties of the
spelling are an almost insuperable obstacle. The French language
in Quebec and the various languages spoken among newly arrived
immigrants in the United States will ultimately meet the same fate,
since a few million illiterate and poverty-stricken habitants of
Canada and a few million laborers in the United States must in the
long run inevitably succumb to the overwhelming power of the world
language of the English people.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account