It is not to be expected that the large majority of humanity that makes
up the populations outside the United States, Great Britain, France,
China, and the Soviet Union can be expected to accept stoically the risk
of even limited quantities of genetic damage, out of any feeling of
loyalty to nations not their own. Even within the populations of the
three major nuclear powers there are strong feelings that the possible
benefits of nuclear testing do not balance the certain dangers.
Public opinion throughout the world is a key factor, then, in enforcing
the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, signed by the governments of the United
States, Great Britain, and the Soviet Union on October 10, 1963.
Effects on Mammals
Although genetic findings on such comparatively simple creatures as
fruit flies and bacteria seem to apply generally to all forms of life,
it seems unsafe to rely on these findings completely in anything as
important as possible genetic damage to man through radiation. During
the 1950s and 1960s, therefore, there have been important studies on
mice, particularly by W. L. Russell at Oak Ridge National Laboratory,
Oak Ridge, Tennessee.
While not as short-lived or as fecund as fruit flies, mice can
nevertheless produce enough young over a reasonable period of time to
yield statistically useful results. Experimenters have worked with
hundreds of thousands of offspring born of mice that have been
irradiated with gamma rays and X rays in different amounts and at
different intensities, as well as with additional hundreds of thousands
born to mice that were not irradiated.
Since mice, like men, are mammals, results gained by such experiments
are particularly significant. Mice are far closer to man in the scheme
of life than is any other creature that has been studied genetically on
a large scale, and their reactions (one might cautiously assume) are
likely to be closer to those that would be found in man.
Almost at once, when the studies began, it turned out that mice were
more susceptible to genetic damage than fruit flies were. The induced
mutation rate per gene seems to be about fifteen times that found in
_Drosophila_ for comparable X ray doses. The only safe course for
mankind then is to err, if it must, strongly on the side of
conservatism. Once we have decided what might be safe on the basis of
_Drosophila_ studies, we ought then to tighten precautions several
notches by remembering that we are very likely more vulnerable than
fruit flies are.
Counteracting the depressing nature of this finding was that of a later,
quite unexpected discovery. It was well established that in fruit flies
and other simple organisms, it was the total dosage of absorbed
radiation that counted and that whether this was delivered quickly or
slowly did not matter.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account