The geographical lore of the time of the Crusades : $b A study in the history of medieval science and tradition in Western EuropeWright, John Kirtland
History
The geographical lore of the time of the Crusades : $b A study in the history of medieval science and tradition in Western Europe
Wright, John Kirtland
Geography -- History; Geography, Medieval
The geographical interest of these figures and of investigations of this
sort was not appreciated by the majority of the men of our age. The
application of astronomical considerations to the problems of navigation
was still in its infancy. The purpose of the investigator of the twelfth
and early thirteenth century in finding geographical coöordinates was
astrological. He wished to make use of them to transpose tables made
originally for the meridian and parallel of one station to the meridian
and parallel of another. Their influence on the cartography of the age
was absolutely _nil_. It is probably safe to make the categorical
statement that the maps and geographical treatises of the century and a
half preceding the year 1250 were drawn and written with almost complete
disregard of any astronomical considerations whatsoever.
CHAPTER XI
CARTOGRAPHY
The maps of our period give us the most convincing possible
illustrations of the geographical ideas that were current.[1127] Their
bright colors, naïve legends, childlike but often skillfully drawn
vignettes, and preposterous inaccuracy take us back into the atmosphere
of a credulous and uncritical age. We can catch much more of the flavor
of the popular geography of the Middle Ages by a hasty glance at one of
the crude Beatus representations of the world than by plowing through
many of the dry pages of compilations like the _De imagine mundi_.
In this chapter there will be given a brief analysis of these maps as
specimens of the cartographer’s art and an explanation of certain points
which all, or most, of them have in common.
_INACCURACY_
What strikes us first is their extraordinary inaccuracy. It is easy to
laugh at this because subconsciously but inevitably we compare the
outlines of seas, continents, and regions as represented in these maps
with the outlines with which we have become familiar in modern atlases.
We tend to forget that the contours of Europe, Asia, and Africa as we
now know them are not images that have been stamped upon the minds of
men at all times, that their accurate representation is the result of a
series of long and laborious observations completed only at a relatively
recent date. Hence it is somewhat unjust to reproach the medieval
cartographer with his inaccuracy, for the reason that accuracy in the
present-day sense was something impossible for him to achieve. The
Greeks and Moslems, to be sure, had made far better maps than did the
men of the Middle Ages; but, unfortunately, Greek maps had perished, few
Arabic maps came through to the West, and the prevalent ignorance of
Greek made it impossible for the Occidental scholar to gain inspiration
from treatises on cartography written in that tongue.
ACCURACY NOT DEEMED NECESSARY
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account