The geographical lore of the time of the Crusades : $b A study in the history of medieval science and tradition in Western EuropeWright, John Kirtland
History
The geographical lore of the time of the Crusades : $b A study in the history of medieval science and tradition in Western Europe
Wright, John Kirtland
Geography -- History; Geography, Medieval
Furthermore, it is a mistake to regard accuracy as the goal and ideal of
the medieval map maker. To gain a sympathetic understanding of his work
we must see what purposes he intended it to fulfill. He drew maps to
accompany and clarify the written texts to which they were usually
subsidiary. The maps were more or less in the nature of diagrammatic
sketches on which the features of the earth’s surface were shown in a
general way, and the draftsman understood perfectly well that all he
could hope to give was a rough approximation to relative positions. The
medieval scribe and map maker was an artist who took pride in the beauty
of his work. The same motives which impelled him to enliven his
manuscript with a multitude of miniatures led him to relieve the coldly
geometrical outlines of his map by lines and colors pleasing to the eye,
by entertaining sketches and readable legends. He was creating something
very different from the modern cartographic or topographic sheet that
stands on its own merits as an independently useful, scientific document
and from which we can get precise information about distances, heights,
positions, and terrain. He would have branded any man a fool who thought
that one could hope to determine from his map the distance from
Jerusalem to England or from the mouth of the Ganges to the mouth of the
Nile. In other words, most medieval maps—including wall maps—were
nothing more than rough diagrams converted into works of art.
When, during the latter years of the thirteenth century, the sailors of
the Mediterranean, driven by the necessity of securing reliable aids to
navigation, began piece by piece to construct marine charts upon which
the contours of the coasts were shown with an approach to modern
correctness, we have indeed a revolution in cartographic art and
geographical science.
Bearing in mind these considerations, we see that the major inaccuracies
of medieval maps are (1) exaggeration in the scale of particular regions
at the expense of others and (2) distortion, often amounting to a
complete failure to show places in their proper relative positions. The
first of these inaccuracies was usually deliberate, the second more or
less unavoidable. Both are well-known characteristics of our modern
American railway folder maps.
EXAGGERATION
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account