The Girl's Own Paper, Vol. XX, No. 1016, June 17, 1899Various
General
The Girl's Own Paper, Vol. XX, No. 1016, June 17, 1899
Various
Children's literature -- Periodicals
“Why?” you may say. “If I can learn all about early civilisation in a
book like Georg Ebers’ _Egyptian Princess_, about mediæval and Scottish
history in Scott’s novels, about the Stuart period in _John Inglesant_,
about music in a story like _Charles Anchester_, about modern problems
of every kind in George Eliot’s, Sir Walter Besant’s, and Mrs. Humphry
Ward’s pages—not to go further—why not confine my reading to this
interesting and attractive form?”
There is an essay by the late Professor T. H. Green of Oxford, which
should be very widely studied.[1] He answers the question “Why not?” in
a most forcible and masterly way, and the gist of his reply is this.
The novel must perforce reproduce the circumstantial view of life; we
are called to look again upon the incidents which day by day distract
our attention overmuch from the “unseen and eternal” realities, and
are apt to be enthralled afresh by the view that “to marry and live
happily ever after” is man’s and woman’s chief end. In other words,
the aspect of things the novelist shows us is “merely the outward and
natural as applied to the inner or ideal.” He cannot give a complete
representation of life; for instance, reproduce its slowness, its
discipline by long years of silent waiting and patient labour. Much
must be omitted of necessity, by reason of conditions of the craft;
much also, by reason of artistic effect, must be so arranged and
rounded off as to give the impression of a happiness impossible in
life. The lesson of life, then, in its completeness, cannot be taught
even by the best novel.
The reading of fiction is valuable in its place, but it is not enough
for the mind and heart to feed upon.
We have not, however, as yet to consider the reading of fiction pure
and simple. There is much besides to occupy attention, and perhaps this
is the place to insist upon the reading of history. To connect the
remote regions of classic lore with the present day, history is needed;
but it is rather overwhelming to look at the best books of history and
see how long and how numerous they are! The primers of history are,
however, within the compass of all.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account