The Girl's Own Paper, Vol. XX. No. 1023, August 5, 1899Various
General
The Girl's Own Paper, Vol. XX. No. 1023, August 5, 1899
Various
Children's literature -- Periodicals
[Illustration: THE GIRL’S OWN PAPER
VOL. XX.—NO. 1023.] AUGUST 5, 1899. [PRICE ONE PENNY.]
SELF-CULTURE FOR GIRLS.
BY LILY WATSON.
[Illustration: OPEN-AIR SKETCHING.]
_All rights reserved._]
PART VII.
After all the serious advice we have given to our readers as to the
literature that is to make them wise, it is pleasant to write of
self-culture through the study of the best poetry.
It is, however, not by deliberately taking poetry as a vehicle of
education, hunting up every allusion, parsing difficult sentences,
and picking the whole thing to pieces, that readers will fall under
its sway and know the power of its magic spell. We have often mourned
in secret at the prevailing fashion of “getting up” this, that, and
the other poem for examinations, and have wondered what such an
introduction to English literature is worth. Of this method of handling
the work of poets one may use Wordsworth’s phrase:
“We murder to dissect.”
Is it desirable, then, to pass by allusions without comprehending
them? Have we not praised the aspiring student who wants to know, for
instance, who was the
“daughter of the gods, divinely tall
And most divinely fair,”
or who it was
“Who saw life steadily and saw it whole,
The mellow glory of the Attic stage,
Singer of sweet Colonus and its child”?
We can only say that, whereas anxiety to understand whatever one reads
intelligently is to be commended, no individual knowledge about a
masterpiece of poetic genius is to be put in place of the masterpiece
itself. And we unhesitatingly condemn the practice of using poems as
vehicles for lessons in grammar, Grimm’s Law, or any other technical
matter whatsoever. For instance, if Wordsworth’s “Excursion” has
any meaning for your heart and mind, do not read it with notes which
stop you four times in the first three lines, with the derivation of
“landscape,” the explanation of “downs” and other kindred matters,
which are undoubtedly useful, but should not be learnt by the medium of
an immortal poem. If you need lessons in this elementary sort of thing,
we should advise you to find them elsewhere.
If you have to read one of Shakespeare’s plays edited by such admirable
commentators as Mr. Aldis Wright or Mr. Verity, do not adopt the
method of the girl who covered up the text, lest it should divert her
attention from the notes! But the notes are the most important matter
to the minds of thousands of middle-class girls and boys, because it is
on the notes they are going to be examined.
A suggestive and amusing essay on this subject for elder readers is to
be found in _Reviews and Essays in English Literature_, by the Rev. D.
C. Tovey, M.A., Clark Lecturer at Trinity College, Cambridge.
The well-known couplet:
“You must love him ere to you
He will seem worthy of your love,”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account