The Girl's Own Paper, Vol. XX, No. 981, October 15, 1898Various
General
The Girl's Own Paper, Vol. XX, No. 981, October 15, 1898
Various
Children's literature -- Periodicals
MARY CARMICHAEL.--The public has been completely fogged over the
subject of tinned meats for years past. Some persons have tried to
prove that tinned articles are better than fresh ones; whilst others
have decided that all preserved foods are poisonous, and that those
who partake of them do so at the risk of their lives. As is usual in
such arguments, the truth lies somewhere between these extreme points,
and we will endeavour to explain what are the various good and bad
qualities of tinned foods. In the first place, we must notice that
tinned eatables are very much better now than they were some years ago.
This is particularly the case with the tinned fruits from California
(the preparation of which is, we believe, entirely carried on by
girls). For some years back we have been able to get tinned pears,
peaches, apricots, etc., from California, and, as far as we can find
out, no case of poisoning has occurred from their consumption. It may
be said that all the tinned articles which are allowed to come into
London are perfectly wholesome while they are fresh; it is only after
they have been kept some time that they become injurious. Again, it
must be remembered that tinned goods will not keep when once the tin
has been opened. A large number of deaths have occurred from eating
tinned meats which have been opened several days previously. It is
of great importance to recognise what the poison in tinned meats is,
and where it comes from. There is a popular notion, which is a very
great fallacy, that the poison is derived from the tins, and that
therefore there is no danger in meats preserved in jars or barrels.
This is a great mistake, for although tinned goods do sometimes become
contaminated with the metal of the tins, this is only very seldom the
case. When the poison is derived from the tins, as it was in some cases
of poisoning from tinned cherries, death is not very common. Whence
comes the poison, of which we all read cases, of whole families being
killed from partaking from a tin of salmon or sardines? It is developed
in the food itself. This is not a case of organic matter going bad
from decay. Articles sealed up in airtight tins will never undergo
putrefaction. This development of poisons in tinned meats is a totally
different phenomenon from putrefaction. It appears that if organic
substances are kept for a long time, whether in the air or in airtight
cases, extraordinary and little-understood changes occur in their
composition, whereby, amongst other things, are developed definite
chemical compounds known as "animal alkaloids." These are the poisonous
agents in tinned goods. These alkaloids are allied, chemically, to
strychnine, morphine, etc., but some of them are immeasurably more
poisonous than any known vegetable or mineral production. A quantity of
one of these alkaloids (occasionally found in tinned sardines), which
is so small as to be almost impossible to demonstrate, has killed a
whole family in twenty-four hours.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account