The glory of the PharaohsWeigall, Arthur E. P. Brome (Arthur Edward Pearse Brome)
History
The glory of the Pharaohs
Weigall, Arthur E. P. Brome (Arthur Edward Pearse Brome)
Egypt -- Antiquities
Dead men are not useless; and the excavator must not cheat the world of
any part of its great perquisite. The dead are the property of the
living, and the archæologist is the world’s agent for the estate of the
grave. The fact that the world does not yet realise the value of its
possessions in this respect is no justification for bad stewardship. A
_dilettante_ can no more amuse himself by excavating carelessly because
the world is not looking than the agent can play the fool with property
which is neglected by its owner. Excavation is only moral when it is
conducted on the strictest scientific lines for the benefit of mankind.
Bad excavating, that is to say, digging for antiquities and not for
information, is not the less dishonest because it happens to break no
law. It cheats the living men of their rightful possessions which,
believe me, are of real practical value to them. It cheats the dead of
their utility, and gives in very truth a sting to death and the victory
to the grave.
In past years professed archæologists have been surprisingly remiss in
regard to the moral principles of excavation. The work of such famous
men as Mariette can only be described as legalised plundering, and there
are not a few diggers at the present day who have no possible right to
touch ancient ground. Mariette made practically no useful records during
the course of his work. For example, we do not know with certainty from
what tomb came the famous statue of _Shêkh-el-beled_, perhaps the
greatest art treasure in Egypt; we do not know how it was found; we do
not know whether it was the _ka_-statue of the deceased standing behind
the altar, or whether it had some other function in the sepulchre; we do
not even know its exact date. It was Mariette’s custom to send a native
overseer to conduct the work for him, and it was his boast that numerous
excavations under his direction were being carried on throughout Egypt
at one and the same time. The antiquities were dug out at a terrific
rate, and were hurled pell-mell into the museum in cart-loads. In more
recent years European gentlemen, and even native antiquity-dealers, have
been given excavating concessions, and have ransacked the ancient tombs
and temples in a mad search for loot, no records being made and no
scientific information being gleaned.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account