The glory of the PharaohsWeigall, Arthur E. P. Brome (Arthur Edward Pearse Brome)
History
The glory of the Pharaohs
Weigall, Arthur E. P. Brome (Arthur Edward Pearse Brome)
Egypt -- Antiquities
or stand over his work all day long no matter how trying the conditions;
who is deft with his fingers as well as with his brain, being able to
photograph, draw, plan, mend, and write fluently; and who can organise
and control his men. There is no harm in allowing a wealthy amateur to
excavate provided that he employs a trained archæologist to do the work
for him and does not interfere in it himself, and also provided that he
intends to make available to the public the antiquities which fall to
his share and all the information which has been gleaned. But there is
very real harm done in giving concessions without the most
strictly-worded licences, in which are clauses precluding all
unscientific work and frustrating all enterprises undertaken entirely
for personal gain. The exploiting of the ancient tombs simply for
mercenary purposes gives the excavator far too much the appearance and
character of a ghoul.
The archæologist, so eager to add to his knowledge by new discoveries,
should remember that there is already quite enough material on hand to
keep him busy for the rest of his life, material which urgently requires
his attention and his protection. The standing monuments of Egypt are
still unstudied in any degree of completeness; and if only the various
antiquarian societies would send out their scholars to make careful
records of the remains which are already accessible, instead of urging
them to unearth something new, Egyptology would be established on a much
more solid basis. What scholars are thoroughly acquainted with the vast
stores of Egyptological material in the museums of the world, or with
the wonderful paintings and reliefs upon the walls of the temples,
tombs, and mortuary chapels now in view throughout Egypt? Why excavate
more remains until these are studied, unless the desired sites are in
danger, or unless some special information is required? Why fill up our
museums with antiquities before public opinion has been sufficiently
educated to authorise the employment of larger numbers of curators? Why
add to the burden of Egypt by increasing the number of monuments which
have to be protected? It is to be remembered that in some cases the
longer an excavation is postponed the better chance there will be of
recording the discoveries adequately. Our methods improve steadily, our
knowledge grows, the number of expert excavators increases; and each
year finds us more fit than formerly we were for the delicate and
onerous task of searching the dead.
It will be seen, then, that excavation is not a thing which may be
lightly entered upon. It is a very serious business, and involves a
grave duty to the public. Even if the arguments in favour of scientific
research which I have suggested at the beginning of this paper are
considered to be those of a casuist, as no doubt they will be by a
certain class of readers, no one will deny that the study of the past
has a broadening influence upon our minds, and therefore is not to be
trifled with.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account