The glory of the PharaohsWeigall, Arthur E. P. Brome (Arthur Edward Pearse Brome)
History
The glory of the Pharaohs
Weigall, Arthur E. P. Brome (Arthur Edward Pearse Brome)
Egypt -- Antiquities
In Egypt, where scientific excavations are conducted entirely by
Europeans and Americans, one has to consider, finally, one’s duty to the
Egyptians, who care not one jot for their history, but who,
nevertheless, as the living descendants of the Pharaohs should be the
nominal stewards of their ancient possessions. What right have we as
foreigners to dig out the graves of the ancient Egyptians?
Our right is a limited one. The Egyptians of the present day have no
interest in antiquities except when considered as merchandise. They have
no idea of what is called scientific work, and excavations conducted by
them have not the slightest similarity to those under the supervision of
modern archæologists. Yet neither the activities of the native plunderer
nor the pressing need for the study of the history of the Nile Valley
permits the Government to refrain altogether from allowing excavation;
and therefore the work has to be done by trained archæologists without
regard to their nationality. This internationalisation of the work can
be justified also on the ground that antiquities of so ancient a kind
are in many respects the property of the whole world; and, following out
this argument, it will at once be apparent that archæologists must work
solely for the benefit of mankind in general, since they are dealing
with the property of all men. By admitting the right of non-Egyptian
scientists to excavate in Egypt because all the world has the right to
hold shares in these mines of information, one admits the existence of
the excavator’s duty to the world. That duty must never be overlooked.
It consists in getting the greatest possible amount of information out
of a discovery with the least possible damage to the things found. Any
excavations authorised in Egypt which are not of an absolutely
scientific character are injustices to the Egyptians and to all men. It
is the business of the Egyptologist to work for the welfare of Egypt as
well as for the benefit of the world; and if he fail to make the relics
of the Pharaohs yield their _full_ burden and act to their _utmost_
capacity for the purpose of teaching the Egyptians of the future the
qualities of their race, and assisting the occupying Power and the world
at large to estimate those qualities and their bearing on modern
thought, then his excavations are not moral and should not be
authorised.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account