The Goose-step: A Study of American EducationSinclair, Upton
History
The Goose-step: A Study of American Education
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States; Universities and colleges -- United States
A woman friend of mine was present at a tea party where the head of a
department in the University of U. G. I. told about a proposed
appointment in the political science department. The man under
discussion was connected with the State Department in Washington. He was
wealthy, said this dean, and had a good social position; his wife’s
mother had especially important social connections. He was right on
Russia, he was right on Japan, he was right on reparations; he had
written the recent note of Secretary Hughes to the Bolshevist delegation
at Genoa, and Hughes had passed this note with only two or three
emendations. Such is the atmosphere in the high-up circles of our
plutocratic education; such are the standards of eminence! I am informed
on the best authority that this sturdy opponent of the Soviet government
in our State Department received three flattering offers from leading
Eastern universities, as soon as it became known that he was the author
of that Hughes note!
Such is the way the game is played. As one professor remarked to me:
“Knowing the ropes as I do, I could get any sort of promotion, any sort
of honors—and that not by worthy work, not by any true contribution to
science, but simply by knowing the interests, and being unscrupulous
enough. It is a situation which destroys the morals of every man who
knows about it.” And another said: “There is not a man in the Wharton
School today who truly respects himself.”
Such are the instructors; and the students are what you would expect.
One professor said to me: “Not five per cent of my men are thinking
about public questions. They take what I teach them as cows in the
pasture take rain, something to be endured but not thought about. They
come from high schools where they have heard no discussions of vital
questions. I have talked with thousands of them; ask anybody in the
university and you will get the same answer—their mental life is as dead
as the tomb.”
Another professor told how one of his colleagues had brought into his
class a former lecturer of the Y. M. C. A. in Siberia, who described to
the students the behavior of Semenoff, the Cossack bandit, one of the
pets of our State Department. The lecturer had traveled in Semenoff’s
train, and had been invited to tea, and Semenoff came in with his tunic
spotted with blood, explaining that he had just dispatched a carload of
prisoners. He had shot them, one by one, with his own revolver, and left
the dead for the American troops to bury. There had been some discussion
of the incident in the class, and not a man there thought there was
anything wrong about it. “They never batted an eye,” said my informant.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account