The Goose-step: A Study of American EducationSinclair, Upton
History
The Goose-step: A Study of American Education
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States; Universities and colleges -- United States
I do not want anyone who reads this book to get the idea that I am so
naive as to imagine that there is no enemy of freedom of teaching save
economic privilege. I know there are others, and all I am doing is
tackle the biggest one first. If I work for the control of universities
by organized farmers and labor unions, it is not because I am unaware
that these groups have their interests and prejudices, but merely
because I believe that these groups can learn to understand true freedom
and justice, whereas I know that a plutocratic class has never been able
to learn anything at any time in human history.
In the University of Wisconsin it is interestingly shown that as soon as
you break down the rule of special privilege, you find yourself
confronted by various kinds of mass prejudice and group interest. The
people of the state consider that they own a university, and they expect
this university to do their way. The question arises—who shall set the
standards, the voters, or the faculty, who think they know more? The
Wisconsin farmer drives up to Madison in his automobile, and demands an
interview with a dean, saying: “Here I am supporting this university by
my taxes, and here you’ve gone and flunked my son!” The farmers’
organizations keep jealous watch over the percentage of “flunkings,” and
if it is too high, they say the university is being made into a place of
academic snobbery. And maybe they are right—it is not so easy to say!
A former state superintendent of education in Wisconsin told me a funny
story. It was proposed to have the normal schools teach engineering, but
President Van Hise of the university said this was impossible; the
university alone could teach engineering, it had mysteriously and
mystically efficient methods of doing so. The superintendent met an
instructor who had recently been taken on in this school, and thinking
he would like to know about these special methods, he asked: “How did
they tell you to teach engineering?”
“They didn’t tell me anything,” said the instructor.
“You mean they gave you no special instructions about how you were to
teach?”
“Nothing at all,” said the other; then he thought—“Oh, yes, to be sure,
they told me to flunk one-third of the students and send them to the
Agricultural School!”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account