The Goose-step: A Study of American EducationSinclair, Upton
History
The Goose-step: A Study of American Education
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States; Universities and colleges -- United States
An interesting aspect of this affair is the behavior of the kept press
of Worcester. One of the students said to me: “I read ‘The Brass Check,’
and I couldn’t believe it, but now I know it is true, because I saw the
Worcester newspapers do practically everything that you told about.”
Throughout the whole affair the students were orderly and dignified; yet
their local newspapers sent over the country wild tales about riots and
threats. The Worcester “Telegram,” in its first account of the incident,
ran the headline: “SPEAKER FLAYS SCHOOLS, CHURCHES, GOVERNMENT”—whereas
Scott Nearing had not once mentioned the government. Next day the
“Telegram” quoted the president of the Liberal Club as saying: “If we
could raise enough money we would engage Upton Sinclair.” This anecdote
is told in the “Clark College Monthly,” a student paper, which declares:
“This statement is without the slightest foundation in fact. Asked by a
reporter if the Liberal Club planned to have any more radical speakers,
as for example, Upton Sinclair, Fraser had replied: ‘Why, he is in
California’; and thus grows the mighty oak!”
One day more, and the “Telegram” buried the students’ official statement
in an obscure page, and ran the headline: “STUDENTS TALK STRIKE, PREXY
SAYS, ‘LET THEM TRY IT’!” The Springfield “Union” declared that the
“notorious Scott Nearing was delivering an anarchistic lecture.”
Throughout the whole affair both these papers referred to the
student-body by such phrases as “irresponsible college boys,”
“make-believe radicals,” “children who should be spanked,” and “sincere
young people of an impressionable age”; entirely concealing the fact
that the average age of Clark students, including the freshman class, is
twenty-one years, while the average of the Liberal Club members at the
time of the Nearing lecture was twenty-five and six-tenths years.
To conclude the story: the protests of the students availed them
nothing. The author of the Frye-Atwood geographies announced his
intention to oversee their activities and their thoughts; and he has
done so. He did not announce his intention to get rid of the professors
who had publicly opposed him, but he proceeded to make it so
uncomfortable for them that they would hasten to remove themselves. The
great tragedy of American academic life is the lack of solidarity of the
faculty. Even the more courageous and public-spirited men among the
Clark faculty did not seem to feel that they owed a duty to the
institution and its traditions; instead of proceeding to organize the
faculty, and to stand as a unit against the degradation of Clark, what
has happened is that six of the best men have resigned in as many
months; they have found congenial places in other institutions, and
their colleagues are left to their fate. As John Jay Chapman puts it:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account