The Goslings: A Study of the American SchoolsSinclair, Upton
History
The Goslings: A Study of the American Schools
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States
Strange as it may seem to you, they are teaching such stuff, not merely
to the children of Belgium and France, but to the children of America
who study French! For example, a standard text-book, Chardenal’s
“Complete French Course,” New and Revised Edition, 1920, is full of the
basest French chauvinism: Germany was the sole author of the war; the
real hero of the world, and of France, is always the warrior; the sacred
places of France are the victorious battle-fields, and the scenes of
peace conferences such as Versailles. The date of the signing of this
most infamous of all the world’s peace treaties has a mystic
significance, because it was four hundred years previously, on that same
day, June 28, 1519, that Charles V was elected Emperor!
There are some really sane men writing on the subject of war and peace
in France at the present time; but never would it do for American school
children to read anything by Anatole France or Romain Rolland! Any more
than it would do for them to read the writings of American
humanitarians, such as Jane Addams or David Starr Jordan. Says Dr.
Jordan, concerning our school text-books:
They have glorified deeds of blood and celebrated most persistently
the heroes of the battle-field. The heroes of peace barely appear on
their pages, and they fail to recognize that the actual heroisms which
have brightened the records of war like flashes of lightning in a
thunderstorm are not products of war. They represent the divine in man
revealed in desperate conditions, in wallowing in physical and moral
mud, midst the barbaric loneliness of war.
And, needless to say, our chambers of commerce with their Riot
Department are going to see that we continue to get text-books of this
sort. Says Colonel Galbraith of this Riot Department, at a May Day
meeting, 1921:
We will see what kind of courses these teachers are giving and what
text-books they use. If we find that they are disloyal we’ll tell you,
and you can kick them out. We don’t care what you do with them.
And in another newspaper item I read:
Captain Walter I. Joyce, chairman of a sub-committee of the
Americanization Committee of the Veterans of Foreign Wars, is
appointed to meet with the representatives of the American Book
Company to scrutinize history text-books gotten out by that company in
order to prevent the creeping in of un-American propaganda. The
investigation of American histories has been going on for the past two
years, and as a result thereof, two histories have been discarded by
the Board of Education of New York and several are under consideration
at the present time in Boston.
This kind of thing has been the rule all over the country, and the
National Council for the Prevention of War has been making a study of
standard text-books of history to determine the result. Here they are,
briefly stated:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account