The Goslings: A Study of the American SchoolsSinclair, Upton
History
The Goslings: A Study of the American Schools
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States
Two years ago a committee of women representing a score of civic
organizations—the Women’s Municipal League, the Women’s Department of
the National Civic Federation, the Civitas Club of Brooklyn, the Women’s
City Club, the League of Catholic Women, etc.—made a careful study of
forty of the school buildings of New York City; they reported that
twenty out of these forty were fire-traps, old wooden buildings with
narrow stairways and no fire escapes. Sanitation was reported “bad” and
“wretched” in twenty-one of these schools, and “fair” in eleven more.
Twenty-one out of thirty-six were in need of repairs, twenty-seven had
only dark basement playgrounds, and so on. I quote a few phrases, just
to give you the flavor of these reports:
Boys’ toilets terrible; no basins and towels.... Toilets old and in
bad condition; foul air unavoidable.... Plumbing too old to operate,
inadequate and unsanitary; few basins and no towels.... Garbage dump
nearby, inexcusable menace to health and comfort of the children....
Twelve toilets for twelve hundred boys, old, bad conditions, bad odor.
No repairs in years, furniture and woodwork almost falling to
pieces.... Fearfully dilapidated; paint and repairs needed on walls;
stairs worn down to danger point.... Buildings so old as to be beyond
repair, should be abandoned.... Insufficient lighting and ventilation;
two rooms with only one window, eight rooms with only two windows....
Fire escapes incomplete and badly constructed.... Wooden buildings, no
fire escapes reported.
These reports were given wide publicity; the ladies waited six months,
over the summer vacation, and then came back to see what had been done.
Out of twenty-three buildings reported dangerous as to fire conditions,
twenty remained unchanged. Only two out of twenty-two schools had made
any improvement as to provisions for the comfort of the teachers. As
regards sanitation, fourteen had been improved, twenty-three had not
been changed; and so on. How much the public authorities were concerned
about such matters was shown by the experience of the Teachers’ Union,
which prepared for an exhibit of the Public Health Association a series
of posters and charts showing the physical condition of the schools.
“Over nine hundred thousand children suffer from lack of a good
ventilation system,” declared one of these posters. “No soap, no water,
no towels,” declared another; and so on. Privately the nurses of the
Health Department at this show all admitted that the posters represented
the truth; but for three days the man who was then commissioner of
health and the man who is now commissioner of health sought desperately
to compel the Teachers’ Union to remove these posters; failing in this,
the publicity agencies of the show cut out all the press notices of the
teachers’ exhibits.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account