The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
I shall point out another great increase of power in national sentiment
which has occurred in the last half-century. I mean that several
very powerful political passions, which were originally independent
of nationalist feeling, have now become incorporated with it. These
passions are: (_a_) The movement against the Jews; (_b_) the movement
of the possessing classes against the proletariat; (_c_) the movement
of the champions of authority against the democrats. To-day each one of
these passions is identified with national feeling and declares that
its adversary implies the negation of nationalism. I may add that when
a person is affected by one of these passions he is generally affected
by all three; consequently nationalist passion is usually swelled by
the addition of all three. Moreover this increase is reciprocal, and
it may be said that to-day capitalism, anti-semitism and the party
of authority have all received new strength from their union with
nationalism. (For additional proof of the strength of these unions, see
Note C at the end of this book.)
I cannot drop the subject of the modern perfecting of political
passions without mentioning one more characteristic: In all nations the
number of persons who feel a direct interest in belonging to a powerful
nation is incomparably greater now than in the past. In all the great
States to-day I observe that not only the world of industry and big
business but a considerable number of small tradesmen, small bourgeois,
doctors, lawyers, and even writers and artists, and working men too,
feel that for the sake of the prosperity of their own occupations it
is essential for them to belong to a powerful group which can make
itself feared. Those who are in a position to give an opinion on
this sort of change agree that the feeling did not exist, at least
in the same clearly defined way as to-day, thirty years ago among
the small tradesmen of France, for instance. It seems an even newer
thing among the men who belong to the so-called liberal professions;
it is certainly something new to hear artists constantly girding at
the government of their country because it ‘does not give the nation
enough prestige to impose their art on foreigners’. The feeling that
from a professional point of view they have an interest in belonging
to a powerful nation is also very recent among the working classes.
The party of ‘Nationalist Socialists’, which seems to exist everywhere
except in France, is a quite modern political development. Among the
masters of industry the new development is, not that they feel how
much it is to their interest that their nation should be powerful,
but that the feeling is to-day transformed into action, into formal
pressure on their governments.[22] This extension of patriotism based
on interest certainly does not prevent this sort of patriotism (as I
said above) from being much less wide-spread than the patriotism[23]
based on pride; nevertheless it brings another increase of strength to
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account