The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
[121] There will be found in Barrès (_Une Enquête aux pays du Levant_,
chap. vii: ‘Les derniers fidèles du Vieux de la Montagne’) a striking
example of admiration for the cult of honour inasmuch as this cult,
when ably exploited by an intelligent leader, gives practical results.
[122] This is especially the case with Montaigne who, as everyone
knows, extols honour insofar as it is man’s sensitiveness to the
judgment of his conscience, but very little insofar as it is a desire
for glory--‘put off with other pleasures that which comes from the
approbation of others.’ Barrès believes he sees in that ‘a foreigner
who does not share our prejudices’. Barrès confuses the moralists and
the poets. Before him I do not know one French author with dogmatic
claims who has attributed a high moral value to the love of glory; the
French moralists before 1890 are very unmilitary, even the soldiers
like Vauvenargues and Vigny. (See the excellent study of G. Le Bidois,
_L’Honneur au miroir de nos lettres_, especially on Montesquieu.)
[123] The Abbé Sertillanges, _L’Héroisme et la Gloire_. Compare this
with Bossuet’s two sermons on ‘The Honour of the World’. You can
measure the advance made by the Church during three centuries in its
concessions to lay passions. See also Nicole: ‘On the true idea of
valour.’ The sermons of the Abbé Sertillanges (‘la Vie Héroïque’)
should be read entire, as a monument of a Churchman’s enthusiasm for
warlike instincts. It is positively the manifesto of a helmed ‘clerk’.
You can find in them such emotions as the following which, mutatis
mutandis, might be an extract from the Regimental Orders of a Colonel
of the Death’s Head Hussars: ‘Behold Guynemer, the young hero, the
simple soul with the eagle glance, the slim Hercules, the Achilles who
does not retire to his tent, the Roland of the clouds and the Cid of
the French sky: was there ever a wilder and more furious paladin, more
careless of death, whether his own or that of an enemy? This “kid”, as
his comrades called him, only enjoyed the savage pleasure of attack, of
the hard fight, of the clear victory, and in him the arrogance of the
conqueror was at once charming and terrible.’
[124] Let me recall Thomas Aquinas’s definition of honour, which is not
exactly the definition of the honour extolled by the Abbé Sertillanges:
‘Honour is good (like the love of human glory) on condition that
charity is its principle, and the love of God or the good of one’s
neighbour as its object.’
[125] See the recent Bill to amend Martial Law, known as the Paul
Boncour Bill.
[126] This suggestive remark is Lavisse’s, _Etudes d’Histoire de
Prusse_, page 30. See the whole passage.
[127] Love here is obviously love for the superior species--to which
the preacher naturally belongs. Doubtless it is this love also which
permits of a pity which is not ‘perverted.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account