The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
[118] This depreciation of Greece, to be seen in many French
traditionalists since de Maistre, is constant among the Pangermanists.
(See notably Houston Chamberlain, _Genesis of the Nineteenth Century_,
tome i, page 57.) In a periodical with dogmatic claims (_Notre Temps_,
August, 1927), under the suggestive title ‘Towards a Practical
Idealism’, I read: ‘A young generation trained in this way, _more
sporting than ideological_, supports those who ask whether we are
not at the dawn of a great age.’ Here again the Churchmen do not
lag behind. In _La Vie Catholique_ (24th September, 1927) I find a
warm eulogy of a champion boxer. It is true that this eulogy ends up
with the words: ‘Finally, let us add that Tunney is a convinced and
practising Catholic, and that two of his sisters are nuns.’
[119] Laws, Book I. The exact text of Plato is: ‘In the order of
virtues, wisdom is first, temperance comes next, courage occupies the
last place.’ Plato here means by courage (see the context, notably the
passage about those soldiers who ‘though insolent, unjust, immoral,
know how to fight’) Man’s aptitude for facing death. It seems that he
would not have given the first place to the courage which is strength
of mind, a resistance to misfortune, as the Stoics afterwards did.
With him strength of mind always comes after justice--according to his
doctrine, it is a consequence of justice. Moreover, the courage placed
in the supreme rank by Barrès is not Stoic patience but the active
defiance of death. For Nietzsche and Sorel it is essential audacity,
where audacity is irrational--a form of courage depreciated by all
ancient moralists and their disciples. (See Plato, Laches; Aristotle,
Ethics, VIII; Spinoza, Ethics, IV, 69; even the poets--‘Our reason
which commands our fire,’ Ronsard.)
It seems that facing death, even on behalf of justice, was not so much
the object of praise among the ancient philosophers as it is among the
moderns. In the Phaedo, Socrates is praised for his justice; he is not
very loudly praised because he died for justice. Moreover, the views
of the ancients on this point seem to me well expressed by Spinoza:
‘Death is a thing of which the free man thinks least of all,’ a thought
which does not imply much admiration for those who face death bravely.
One wonders whether the veneration of courage, at least among the
moralists, has not been created by Christianity, with the importance it
attaches to death, and the subsequent appearance before God.
I cannot leave this point without recalling a passage where Saint-Simon
speaks of a nobility ‘accustomed to be good for nothing except to get
itself killed’, _Mémoires_, t. xi, page 427, ed. Cheruel. It may be
asserted that there is not one modern writer, even a Duke of France,
who would speak of courage in such a tone.
[120] And to hold.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account