The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs) — John Shaqi
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
Ever since these systems have been in existence, they have consisted
in establishing for each passion that it is the agent of good in the
world and that its enemy is the genius of evil. But to-day these
passions desire to establish this not only politically, but morally,
intellectually and aesthetically. Anti-semitism, Pangermanism, French
Monarchism, Socialism are not only political manifestations; they
defend a particular form of morality, of intelligence, of sensibility,
of literature, of philosophy and of artistic conceptions. Our age has
introduced two novelties into the theorizing of political passions, by
which they have been remarkably intensified. The first is that everyone
to-day claims that his movement is in line with ‘the development of
evolution’ and ‘the profound unrolling of history’. All these passions
of to-day, whether they derive from Marx, from M. Maurras or from
Houston Chamberlain, have discovered a ‘historical law’, according to
which their movement is merely carrying out the spirit of history and
must therefore necessarily triumph, while the opposing party is running
counter to this spirit and can enjoy only a transitory triumph. That
is merely the old desire to have Fate on one’s side, but it is put
forth in a scientific shape. And this brings us to the second novelty:
To-day all political ideologies claim to be founded on science, to
be the result of a ‘precise observation of facts’. We all know what
self-assurance, what rigidity, what inhumanity (comparatively new
traits in the history of political passions, of which modern French
monarchism is a good example) are given to these passions to-day by
this claim.
To summarize: To-day political passions show a degree of universality,
of coherence, of homogeneousness, of precision, of continuity, of
preponderance, in relation to other passions, unknown until our
times. They have become conscious of themselves to an extent never
seen before. Some of them, hitherto scarcely avowed, have awakened to
consciousness and have joined the old passions. Others have become more
purely passionate than ever, possess men’s hearts in moral regions
they never before reached, and have acquired a mystic character which
had disappeared for centuries. All are furnished with an apparatus of
ideology whereby, in the name of science, they proclaim the supreme
value of their action and its historical necessity. On the surface
and in the depths, in spatial values and in inner strength, political
passions have to-day reached a point of perfection never before known
in history. The present age is essentially the age of politics.
II
_Significance of this Movement--Nature of Political Passions_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account