The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
If, therefore, we desire to express this perfecting of political
passions which I have described, in terms of a more profound and
essential order of things, we may say that men to-day are displaying,
with a hitherto unknown knowledge and consciousness, the desire to
situate themselves in the _real_ or practical manner of existence, in
opposition to the _disinterested_ or _metaphysical_ manner. Moreover,
it is remarkable to see how political passions to-day more and more
expressly assert their derivation from this realism and from it alone.
On the one hand we have a Socialism which constantly declares that it
has no interest in universal man, no interest in procuring justice for
him or any other ‘metaphysical phantom’, but solely desires to obtain
possession of material advantages for the benefit of its class. On the
other hand we have the nationalist mind which everywhere takes a pride
in being purely realistic. The French people who fought in the past to
carry to other nations a doctrine they believed would bring happiness
(I say the people, for its rulers never shared in that simple-minded
belief) would now blush to have it even suspected that they would fight
‘for principles’.[26] Is it not suggestive to observe that the only
wars of the past which, to some extent, brought into play passions
that were a little disinterested--the wars of religion--are the only
wars from which humanity has freed itself?[27] And that immense
idealistic upheavals like the crusades (idealistic at least with humble
people) should now be something which makes the modern man smile, like
the spectacle of children at play? Is it not also significant that the
national passions (which I have shown are the most perfectly realist of
all political passions) should be those which I have been able to point
out have most absorbed all other passions?[28] Let me add to this,
that these passions, insofar as they are the will of a group of men to
set themselves up as distinct from others, have attained a hitherto
unknown degree of consciousness.[29] Finally, the supreme attribute we
have discovered in political passions, i.e. the divinization of their
realism, is now openly admitted, with a plainness never seen before.
The State, Country, Class, are now frankly God; we may even say that
for many people (and some are proud of it) they alone are God.[30]
Humanity, by its present practice of political passions, thereby
declares that it has become more realist, more exclusively and more
religiously realist than it has ever been.
III
_The ‘Clerks’--The Great Betrayal_
_‘I created him to be spiritual in his flesh; and now he has become
carnal even in the spirit.’_--(Bossuet, _Élévations_, VII, 3.)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account