The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
In the first place they affect a large number of men they never before
affected. When, for example, we study the civil wars which convulsed
France in the sixteenth century, and even those at the end of the
eighteenth century, we are struck by the small number of persons
whose minds were really disturbed by these events. While history, up
to the nineteenth century, is filled with long European wars which
left the great majority of people completely indifferent, apart from
the material losses they themselves suffered,[1] it may be said that
to-day there is scarcely a mind in Europe which is not affected--or
thinks itself affected--by a racial or class or national passion, and
most often by all three. The same progress seems to have taken place
in the New World, while immense bodies of men in the Far East, who
seemed to be free from these impulses, are awakening to social hatred,
the party system, and the national spirit insofar as it implies the
will to humiliate other men. To-day political passions have attained a
_universality_ never before known.
They have also attained _coherence_. Thanks to the progress of
communication and, still more, to the group spirit, it is clear
that the holders of the same political hatred now form a compact
impassioned mass, every individual of which feels himself in touch
with the infinite numbers of others, whereas a century ago such
people were comparatively out of touch with each other and hated in
a ‘scattered’ way. This is singularly striking with respect to the
working classes who, even in the middle of the nineteenth century,
felt only a scattered hostility for the opposing class, attempted only
dispersed efforts at war (such as striking in one town, or one union),
whereas to-day they form a closely-woven fabric of hatred from one
end of Europe to the other. It may be asserted that these coherences
will tend to develop still further, for the will to group is one of
the most profound characteristics of the modern world, which even in
the most unexpected domains (for instance, the domain of thought)
is more and more becoming the world of leagues, of ‘unions’ and of
‘groups’. Is it necessary to say that the passion of the individual
is strengthened by feeling itself in proximity to these thousands
of similar passions? Let me add that the individual bestows a mystic
personality on the association of which he feels himself a member, and
gives it a religious adoration, which is simply the deification of his
own passion, and no small stimulus to its intensity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account