The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)Benda, Julien
Philosophy
The great betrayal (La trahison des clercs)
Benda, Julien
Intellectuals; Nationalism; Philosophy, Modern
It will be observed that these passages from Nietzsche praise the
military life apart from any political aim.[116] And, in fact, the
modern ‘clerks’ teach men that war implies a morality _in itself_
and should be exercised even apart from any utility. This thesis, so
familiar in Barrès, has been defended in its full splendour by a young
hero who is an educator of the soul for a whole French generation:
‘In my country we love war and secretly desire it. We have always made
war. Not to conquer a province, not to exterminate a nation, not to
settle a conflict of interests.... We make war for the sake of making
war, with no other purpose.’[117]
The old French moralists, even the soldiers (Vauvenargues, Vigny),
looked upon war as a sad necessity; their descendants recommend it as
a noble inutility. Yet, here again, the cult preached as apart from
the practical and as an art happens to be eminently favourable to the
practical--useless war is the best preparation for useful war.
This teaching leads the modern ‘clerk’ (we have just seen it in
Nietzsche) to confer a _moral_ value upon physical exercise and to
proclaim _the morality of sport_--a most remarkable thing indeed among
those who for twenty centuries have exhorted man to situate good in
states of the mind. The moralists of sport, moreover, do not all
shuffle over the practical essence of their doctrine. Young people,
Barrès clearly teaches, should be trained in physical strength, for the
greatness of the country. The modern educator goes for his inspiration,
not to those who strolled in the Lyceum or to the solitaries of
Clairvaux, but to the founder of a little town in the Peloponnesus.
Moreover, our age has seen this new thing: Men who claim to belong
to the spiritual life teaching that the Greece to venerate is Sparta
with her gymnasiums, not the city of Plato or Praxiteles, while others
maintain that in antiquity we should honour Rome and not Greece. All
these things are perfectly consistent in those who desire to preach to
humanity nothing but strong constitutions and solid ramparts.[118]
The preaching of realism leads the modern ‘Clerk’ to certain teachings,
whose novelty in his history is not sufficiently noticed, nor what a
break they form with the teaching which his class has given to men for
the past two thousand years.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account