The great Persian War and its preliminaries : $b A study of the evidence, literary and topographicalGrundy, G. B. (George Beardoe)
History
The great Persian War and its preliminaries : $b A study of the evidence, literary and topographical
Grundy, G. B. (George Beardoe)
Greece -- History -- Persian Wars, 500-449 B.C.
The current at this point in the Hellespont does not follow the middle
line of the strait. There is a strong bend off Abydos, the channel,
which up to this point comes from the Propontis in a south-west
direction, turning due south. The current accordingly struck the
European shore near Sestos, and then rebounded on to the Asian shore
at Abydos (_cf_. Strabo, xiii. p. 591). The eastern bridge, therefore,
which went from Abydos in a line not greatly divergent from the
direct line from Abydos to Sestos, would have an axis inclined at
an acute angle to the line of the current at this point; therefore,
when Herodotus says its supporting vessels were oblique, does he mean
oblique to this line of current, as they would be, if their axes were
in their ordinary position at right angles to the axis of the bridge;
or has he in his mind a different kind of obliquity, _i.e._ were they
slewed round in such a way that their prows pointed up the stream,
which was itself oblique at this point?
As a practical question of engineering, it is infinitely more probable
that the latter was the case. The capable engineers who constructed
the bridge were extremely unlikely, in view of the fate of their
predecessors, to expose their work to the enormous strain which the
position of its supporting boats all but broadside on to the line of
current would have involved.
It cannot, however, be said that it is certain that Herodotus
would have thus interpreted his own description. At the same time,
descriptions by the ancients involving a reference to relative
positions have to be treated with the greatest caution. It is often the
case that the strictest meaning of their words is proved by the context
not to be the sense they wish to convey. In these days of maps and
instruments of precision, we are infinitely more strict, or, perhaps,
less liable to error in orientation, than those who did not possess
such things, save in the rudest possible form.
One of the commonest forms of mistake among ancient writers, in the
course of a description, is to alter the point of view, or the object
to whose position the positions of other objects are being referred.
Polybius conspicuously does so in describing the valley running up
from Lake Trasimene. A few chapters further on, Herodotus does the
same thing (vii. 42), for he describes the Persians in their march as
leaving Mount Ida on the _left_, whereas he should have said _right_,
thus confusing his own point of view from the sea with theirs.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account