But if it be necessary that we should always have a powerful armed
force ready for action, it is equally important that that force should
be acquainted with its trade. Lapped in peace, and surrounded by
visions of wealth, Englishmen have said, “We fear not war, we know we
are always in possession of the sinews of it.” But they have found
themselves mistaken: a soldier can no more be made in a day by the
influence of money, than a lawyer can; half a century of official
duties will not make a general, nor will all the experiences of the
hunting-field teach a dashing nobleman to lead on a charge of cavalry,
with a due regard to human life or a judgment that may insure success.
In all the disasters we have encountered in the Crimea, the courage
and physical strength of our soldiers have signalized themselves,
even beyond our hopes; but the readers of history--particularly that
part of it which relates to war--perceive at once that our leaders
have been wanting in that genius or knowledge which has distinguished
great captains. With all our respect for the fine and gentlemanly
qualities of the lamented Lord Raglan, we cannot subdue a conviction
that if a Hannibal, an Alexander, a Cæsar, a Belisarius, a Turenne,
a Condé, a Marlborough, or even a Suwarrow,[1] had been at the head
of such a gallant band, Sebastopol would have been subdued long ago.
I do not think that either Buonaparte or his conqueror was eminently
distinguished in this branch of the art of war. It is not often that
a man can, like Clive, go from the desk to the battle-field, and at
once become a great general; or that so young a man as Wolfe can take a
Quebec. In guerilla or partisan warfare, unprepared but enthusiastic
men sometimes make successful leaders; but to handle great masses of
troops, or to besiege strongly-fortified cities, whatever a general’s
genius may be, he must have a training in the active practice of his
profession.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account