"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in RussiaSpargo, John
History
"The Greatest Failure in All History": A Critical Examination of the Actual Workings of Bolshevism in Russia
Spargo, John
Communism -- Russia
Discontent and hatred against the Bolsheviks are now so strong
that a shock or the knowledge of approaching help would
suffice to make the people rise and annihilate the Communists.
Considering this discontent and hatred, it would seem that
elections to different councils should produce candidates of
other parties. Nevertheless all councils consist of Communists.
The explanation is very plain. That freedom of election of
which the Bolsheviks write and talk so much consists in the
free election of certain persons, a list of which had already
been prepared. For instance, if in one district six delegates
have to be elected, seven to eight names are mentioned, of
which six can be chosen. Very characteristic in this respect
were the elections February last in the district of ----,
Moscow Province, where I have one of my estates. Nearly all
voters, about 200, of which twelve Communists, came to the
district town. Seven delegates had to be elected and only seven
names were on the prepared list, naturally all Communists.
The local Soviet invited the twelve communistic voters to a
house, treated them with food, tea, and sugar, and gave each
ten rubles per day; the others received nothing, not even
housing. But they, knowing what they had to expect from former
experiences, had provided for such an emergency and decided
to remain to the end. The day of election was fixed and put
off from day to day. After four postponements the Soviet saw
no way out. The result was that the seven delegates elected
by all against twelve votes belonged to the Octobrists and
Constitutional-Democrats. But these seven and a number of the
wealthier voters were immediately arrested as agitators against
the Soviet Republic. New elections were announced three days
later, but this time the place was surrounded by machine-guns.
The next day official papers announced the unanimous election
of Communists in the district of Verea. After a short time
peasant revolts started. To put down these, Chinese and Letts
were sent and about 300 peasants were killed. Then began
arrests, but it is not known how many were executed.
Finally, there is the testimony of the workman, Menshekov, member
of the Social Democratic Party, who was himself given an important
position in one of the largest factories of Russia, the Ijevsky
factory, in the Urals, when the Bolsheviki assumed control. This simple
workman was not, and is not, a “reactionary monarchist,” but a Social
Democrat. He belonged to the same party as Lenin and Trotsky until the
withdrawal of these men and their followers and the creation of the
Communist Party. Menshekov says:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account