Orators -- Greece; Oratory, Ancient; Speeches, addresses, etc., Greek -- History and criticism
The general contents of the _Panegyricus_ have already been discussed,
but only a careful study of the speech will reveal the skill with which
one topic is made to lead up to another, the nice proportion of the
parts, and the adroitness displayed in gathering and binding together the
various threads of the argument. Numerous paragraphs which seem at first
to be almost digressions are found, when we take the speech as a whole,
to be essential to its unity, and though in its course a large number of
topics is handled, the main subject is never left out of view. The level
of style is high throughout, and no extracts can properly represent it.
A short analysis may, however, serve to indicate the coherence of the
arguments:[211]
‘I am here to offer advice about the necessity of war with
Persia and unity among the Greeks. Others have handled the same
theme, but the fact of their failure renders any excuse for
a fresh attempt superfluous, and the subject admits of being
treated better than it has been’ (§§ 1-14).
‘My predecessors have missed an important point; that nothing
can be done until the leaders—Athens and Sparta—are reconciled,
and persuaded to share the leadership.
‘Sparta has accepted a false tradition, that leadership is hers
by ancestral right. I shall try to prove that the leadership
really belongs to Athens; Sparta then should consent to a joint
command’ (§§ 15-20).
‘Athens first possessed maritime empire, and her civilization
is the oldest in Greece (§§ 21-25). Her claims to hegemony are
as follows:—
‘A. (_a_) Tradition, which has never been refuted, records that
Athens first provided the necessities of life. Demeter taught
in Attica the cultivation of corn and instituted the Mysteries.
‘(_b_) Athens undoubtedly led the way in colonization, thus
enlarging the boundaries of Greek land, and driving back the
barbarians (§§ 28-37).
‘(_c_) Athens had the earliest laws, and the earliest
constitution. She established the Piraeus, the centre of Greek
trade. She provides in herself a perpetual festival, at which
the arts are encouraged. Practical philosophy and oratory are
so highly honoured at Athens that the name “Greek” is applied
properly not by claim of blood but by virtue of the possession
of Athenian culture (§§ 38-50).
‘B. (_a_) From heroic times downwards Athens has shown herself
the helper of the oppressed. Even Sparta grew great through her
support (§§ 57-65).
‘(_b_) Athens in the earliest times and in the Persian Wars
distinguished herself against the barbarians (§§ 66-74).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account