Jewish philosophy -- Early works to 1800; Judaism -- Works to 1900; Philosophy, Medieval -- Early works to 1800
We have already stated, in one of the chapters of this treatise, that
there is a great difference between bringing to view the existence of a
thing and demonstrating its true essence. We can lead others to notice
the existence of an object by pointing to its accidents, actions, or
even most remote relations to other objects: e.g., if you wish to
describe the king of a country to one of his subjects who does not know
him, you can give a description and an account of his existence in many
ways. You will either say to him, the tall man with a fair complexion
and grey hair is the king, thus describing him by his accidents; or you
will say, the king is the person round whom are seen a great multitude
of men on horse and on foot, and soldiers with drawn swords, over whose
head banners are waving, and before whom trumpets are sounded; or it is
the person living in the palace in a particular region of a certain
country; or it is the person who ordered the building of that wall, or
the construction of that bridge; or by some other similar acts and
things relating to him. His existence can be demonstrated in a still
more indirect way, e.g., if you are asked whether this land has a king,
you will undoubtedly answer in the affirmative. “What proof have you?”
“The fact that this banker here, a weak and little person, stands
before this large mass of gold pieces, and that poor man, tall and
strong, who stands before him asking in vain for alms of the weight of
a carob-grain, is rebuked and is compelled to go away by the mere force
of words; for had he not feared the king, he would, without hesitation,
have killed the banker, or pushed him away and taken as much of the
money as he could.” Consequently, this is a proof that this country has
a ruler and his existence is proved by the well-regulated affairs of
the country, on account of which the king is respected and the
punishments decreed by him are feared. In this whole example nothing is
mentioned that indicated his characteristics, and his essential
properties, by virtue of which he is king. The same is the case with
the information concerning the Creator given to the ordinary classes of
men in all prophetical books and in the Law. For it was found necessary
to teach all of them that God exists, and that He is in every respect
the most perfect Being, that is to say, He exists not only in the sense
in which the earth and the heavens exist, but He exists and possesses
life, wisdom, power, activity, and all other properties which our
belief in His existence must include, as will be shown below. That God
exists was therefore shown to ordinary men by means of similes taken
from physical bodies; that He is living, by a simile taken from motion,
because ordinary men consider only the body as fully, truly, and
undoubtedly existing; that which is connected with a body but is itself
not a body, although believed to exist, has a lower degree of existence
on account of its dependence on the body for existence.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account