The heart of the railroad problem: The history of railway discrimination in the United States, the chief efforts at control and the remedies proposed, with hints from other countriesParsons, Frank
History
The heart of the railroad problem: The history of railway discrimination in the United States, the chief efforts at control and the remedies proposed, with hints from other countries
Parsons, Frank
Railroads -- Freight -- Rates -- United States; Railroads and state -- United States
Railroad men in high position declare that discriminations always will
exist. President Ripley of the Santa Fe says: “The situation is
practically remediless. I think it will always be.”[351] President J. J.
Hill of the Great Northern says: “You may say there shall be no
discrimination. But that condition will never exist. If there were no
discrimination the people would come down here in great throngs and ask
you to authorize discrimination. We have to discriminate.”[352] When I
asked President Fish of the Illinois Central how discriminations could
be stopped he said: “Tell me how to enforce the Ten Commandments and
I’ll tell you how to stop discriminations.” Another railroad president,
whose name I am not at liberty to give, said in reply to the same
question: “Discriminations will never cease so long as there is
competition among the railroads, or political favors and protection can
be secured thereby, or railways and railway men are interested in other
businesses than transportation.” President Hill also recognizes the
factor of special self-interest in addition to the influence of
competition. He says: “I think that every railway officer in this
country should be disqualified from having any interest, directly or
indirectly, in any large producer of traffic, whether it is a coal mine
or a factory or a mill or anything else, on a line of railway where he
is on the pay roll.”
“SENATOR CLAPP. And the reason for that suggestion is what?
“MR. HILL. That he cannot be fair to the other fellow and punish
himself.
“SENATOR CLAPP. And the opportunity is such that it cannot be detected
and prevented?
“MR. HILL. It is so easy, if there is a great demand for coal in one
direction, or for some commodity in one place, for him to help one
fellow and forget the other.”[353]
One of the gravest dangers lies in the fact that men who are largely
interested in the great industrial corporations control certain railway
lines and have large influence with many others. The interlocking of
railroad interests with other industrial interests is a cause of
discrimination second only to the pressure of railroad competition for
traffic that is used by shippers as a means of extorting the favors they
desire.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account