The Historical Jesus: A Survey of PositionsRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Historical Jesus: A Survey of Positions
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ -- Historicity; Jesus Christ -- Rationalistic interpretations
But however that may be, we have to note that for M. Loisy the
promise of reward at the judgment for help given to the distressed
is not a Jesuine utterance. It occurs only in Matthew; and we may
readily agree that, if such an allocution were really delivered by
the alleged Founder, it could not conceivably have been left to one
collector to preserve it. "The redactor of the first Gospel," comments
M. Loisy in his best critical vein, "thought he ought to put this here
to complete his collection of instructions concerning the parousia
and the great judgment. It is ... a piece in which is developed,
from the point of view of the last judgment, the word of the Lord:
'He that receiveth you receiveth me.'" So that a teaching which still
makes a great impression on the Christian consciousness is confessedly
but a development by an unknown hand of a bare Messianic phrase. "It
has been visibly arranged to close the compilation of discourses and
parables made here by the redactor of the first Gospel." [192]
Yet when we come to the parable of the Good Samaritan, which occurs
only in Luke, and which also cannot be conceived as being deliberately
omitted by the previous evangelists if it had been uttered by
the Master, M. Loisy indulges in a very long discourse that reads
like a preserved sermon, only to conclude that "the parable of the
Samaritan thus offers itself as one of the most authentic testimonies
[un témoignage authentique entre tous] of the teaching of Jesus. It
is clear that the evangelist has not invented it, but that he has
found it ready made, and that he has only given it a frame, in his
fashion." [193] It is with a certain embarrassment over the spectacle
of a good scholar's divagation that one proceeds to point to the
absolute non sequitur in M. Loisy's comment. Supposing we agree that
the evangelist found the parable ready made, wherein is this case
differentiated from that of the passage in Matthew last noted? That
is at least as likely to have been found ready made; yet it is not in
that case claimed by M. Loisy that the passage is therefore a record of
a real Jesuine utterance. He sees that it is a "patch," a development.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive