The historical novel : $b An essayButterfield, Herbert
History
The historical novel : $b An essay
Butterfield, Herbert
Historical fiction -- History and criticism
To the politician, the important movements and striking decisions and
big crises that for him are “history,” are things within reach; the
military man has not much difficulty in recovering the noisy things
that for him are “history”; the diplomatist knows where to look for
the story of international tangles, and the mysteries of pacts and
treaties and the hidden sources of power in a state; court and camp
and parliament house are rich with documents and records; the things
that are played out in the limelight, the stately public events are,
in a way, simple to the historian, and the men who talk of democracies
and regiments and alliances, and who think of people in the mass
and can find food in statistics and budgets--these can discuss the
condition of England and the welfare of the people. But they are far
from life. Now the “huts where poor men lie” elude the world’s Memory.
The ploughman whom Gray saw, plodding his weary way, the rank and file
of Monmouth’s rebel crowd--every man of them a world in himself, a
mystery of personality, more wonderful than a star--the tavern-keepers
whom Puritan England strove to root out--these have left no memorial
and all that we know about them is just enough to set us guessing and
wondering. The things by which we remember an old friend--his peculiar
laugh, his way of drawing his hand through his hair, his whistle in the
street, his humour, and the sound of his footstep on the stair--these
things, at any rate, we cannot hope to recapture in history, any more
than we can recapture last night’s sunset, or hear again a song sung
by Jenny Lind. The most homely and intimate and personal things slip
through the hands of the historian. The history that the romanticist in
us longs for, the desire to touch the pulsing heart of men who toyed
with the world as we do, and left it long ago, is the quest for the
most elusive thing in the world. We who cannot know our own friends,
save in a fragmentary way and at occasional moments of self-revelation,
cannot hope to read the hearts of half-forgotten kings. We cannot hope
to get close to the lives of humble men who trod silently through the
world. These we cannot fasten upon at all; history is thwarted; Earth
cannot remember.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account